Advanced search

HiFace BNC or RCA?

Posted by: AMA on 28 January 2010

My Naim DAC is coming next week.

I plan to connect it to Logitech Transporter BNC output (transformer coupled) with Naim DC1 BNC-BNC. This will occupy one DAC's BNC input but the second BNC will be still available.

The other source will be PC/USB. I plan to go for HiFace USB. It's available in two options: RCA and BNC.
So shall I go for BNC or what?
Posted on: 10 February 2010 by AMA
So why should I go for HiFace BNC with expensive DC1 if this will not give me a top-quality digital bitstream? I have already ordered one DC1 for my TP-->DAC setup. Why buy the second? Instead I can use Hiface RCA with my Klotz coax RCA (not a bad coax BTW) to watch DVDs through the Naim DAC.

What do you say, js? Can you here a difference between HiFaceBNC/DC1 and HiFaceRCA/RegularCoax through the Naim DAC?
Posted on: 10 February 2010 by js
Seems reasonable to have just the one for the music portion if you already like the other for vid. I can hear the difference in DIG cables and BNC vs RCA. If I were you, I'd get a bnc adapter for a quid and try the DC1 there to find out if it matters enough with that source.
Posted on: 10 February 2010 by Former member
quote:
Originally posted by js:
Seems reasonable to have just the one for the music portion if you already like the other for vid. I can hear the difference in DIG cables and BNC vs RCA. If I were you, I'd get a bnc adapter for a quid and try the DC1 there to find out if it matters enough with that source.
John,
Dont you just want to give up some times and just go and pull your hair out? Roll Eyes
Stu
Posted on: 10 February 2010 by js
Well maybe not mine and of coarse, I'd use a proxy.
Posted on: 10 February 2010 by AMA
js, you mean the one on top is BNC and the blond beneath is RCA? You got a deep sense of allegory Winker
Posted on: 11 February 2010 by AMA
I have recollected the shards of diligence and run the "RCA coax vs Tosslink" contest .
Tosslink is Van Den Hul Optocoupler and RCA coax is Klotz Reference.
Both are < 100 $ staff (I bought both long ago and forgot the actual price).
The difference is very marginal. RCA coax is a bit cleaner and transients are better including bass. It's very audible on high quality tracks with low scale music -- like jazz trio, guitar.
But it's also easy to pick up the difference on the background of mellow songs -- I clearly hear it on Boz Scaggs.
The difference is not clearly pronounced on aggressive rock or complex orchestral passages.
I also failed to track a difference in voices.
Anyway it was a good session -- I'm fully convinced to change for BNC coax route both for TP and PC.

If DC1 will not 'play back' my investments I shall consider it as charity to Naim which we all love anyway Smile