Transparency scanners

Posted by: Bruce Woodhouse on 08 April 2010

I am able to scan slides on my home flatbed but the results are only so-so. A recent trawl through my myriad boxes of slides has made me think about scanning a percentage for storage and preservation. It is noticeable how some are fading (mostly the non fuji stock).

Anyone using a decent slide/negative scanner? Anything I should look out for/avoid when hunting for one? What do I need to sepnd to get decent quality within reason?

I am also wondering about just having them done commercially since the costs look pretty reasonable.

Bruce
Posted on: 08 April 2010 by Eloise
At a low price range there are several from Plustek (£200 to 400). The professionals still use the Nikon Coolscan though the current model is around £3000.

Might be worth giving your local Jessops or independent camera shop a ring, see if they have any in stock you could demo - take some slides in and scan see if the quality is up to your exceptions.

Just found this website - http://www.filmscanner.info/en...nerTestberichte.html - which maybe of help / interest.

Eloise
Posted on: 08 April 2010 by SC
Bruce - I'm lucky enough to own & use a high end-end Imacon film scanner for my professional work (think along the lines of a 555 for costs!) but one of the first decent consumer scanners I ever owned was from the Nikon range....At the time and the price range, they pretty much had the market wrapped up...Very good scanners within reason. I'm not sure what the models and prices are at now, but I'm sure there are probably plenty going around used as folk dump them for digi cameras - If just needing 35mm, then something from the 4000, 5000 models up should be great...there are also many add on elements that may be of use - I remember having the auto feeder for mounted slides which was a very handy feature at the time.....

One good thing about the Nikons is they feature (think they still do ?) their own dust/blemish removal software, which generally works a treat and saves many hours of spotting & retouching, particularly on older/poor condition slides...(something I dream of at times!, but is unsuitable for pre-press use as the scans are actually slightly 'softer')....

If you're comparing a few different models, have a look at the quoted D-max levels (though sometimes take with a pinch of salt!) - the higher the figure towards 5, the better the ability the scanner has to scan dark/shadow area and pull out detail - particularly useful with trannies....

Hope this helps a little,

Steve.
Posted on: 08 April 2010 by Rockingdoc
I use and recommend a Nikon Coolscan, and quite a few appear cheaply on a well known internet auction site.
Posted on: 08 April 2010 by Derek Wright
Take a look on eBay - slide scanners are often bought for a limited life project and then sold on - so you essentially have to fund the loan of the scanner from the world and may get most of your money back when you sell it back to the world.

You risk is that the scanner fails or requires a repair.
Posted on: 08 April 2010 by northpole
Bruce
I have a Nikon Coolscan 5000ED along with an auto slide feeder accessory (SF-210).

This produces very high quality scans and you can leave the scanner and computer to trundle through a bundle of slides automatically.

Derek's advice is good - keep your eyes peeled on e-bay and enjoy a discounted price sure in the knowledge that once you have scanned your slides, you too could sell on for little or no loss on the purchase price.

Peter
Posted on: 08 April 2010 by Bruce Woodhouse
Thanks for the advice everyone. I'll be 'scanning' Ebay.

Bruce
Posted on: 09 April 2010 by Rockingdoc
Glad to see that you are at your desk for these extended hours.
Posted on: 09 April 2010 by Bruce Woodhouse
quote:
Originally posted by Rockingdoc:
Glad to see that you are at your desk for these extended hours.


Aren't we all?

Anyway 'The early bird catches the wor(m/k)'

Bruce