UQ - want to get NAS but....

Posted by: living in lancs yearning for yorks on 29 September 2012

I have no idea where to start... have just bought Unitiqute - at £850 for an ex-dem it seemed rude not to!

 

The UQ is essentially to get some music in the loft where I work 2-3 days a week (or more).  It will also take in from playstation 3, and I have FM and DAB aerial sockets available.  Internet a bit of a sore point - using 3G modem/router with external aerial.  Poor speed between 3pm and 9pm weekdays (and weekends) but otherwise OK, though probably not enough to be able to enjoy internet radio (not that I have tried yet).  We live at the end of the lines from the phone exchange so waiting possibly years before can have regular internet, though

 

To now, I have been listening to stuff in itunes on my mac air through apple cinema screen but that isn't really satisfactory.  To start with I am just going to use some old mission 70 speakers (my first ever speakers bought in 1985!) but in the longer term I will do something else, not sure what

 

I think I want to get a NAS set up, as I want to get an NDS for the main system downstairs in due course (probably to replace the CDS2 - which runs through XPS2, 52/SC2, 250 olive into SBLs) - and being able to tap into my cd collection (around 600-700 or so) from the room where the hifi is and the loft as well is attractive.  I am unlikely to add any access anywhere else, though I suppose my daughters might want to be able to access in their rooms (problem there as there is a thick stone wall between the front part of the house where the loft, living room and main bedroom are, and the back where the family room/kitchen and children's bedrooms are)

 

Problem is, I know I need a new router/modem thing (budget to to £200-ish to get something heavy duty that will replace the cheap rubbish I got when the 3G / aerial were sorted - that will take a 3G sim card and also connect into mainstream broadband if that ever works), plus a NAS drive plus software maybe to rip from one of my macs.  We do have an iMac with a 1TB hard drive that is woefully underused (family computer in same room as main hifi system downstairs) but it might be better to have a separate NAS drive, maybe a Qnap with mirrored drives?  Prefer to keep under £500 if possible but don't mind spending a bit more for the right thing

 

I have tried reading a few threads on here but consistently get rather lost rather quickly as the terminology goes flying over my head!  Is there somewhere I can go and read an easy to follow guide as to what to do?  I have spoke to a couple of different dealers and I keep getting lost in what they say...

 

I like to take a long term view and upgrade infrequently - so, since 1985, I am on my third turntable, third cd player, third set of speakers, fourth amp - which is much slower than many (if not all) people on here.  I would rather spend a bit more and have something that will last...

 

If it makes any difference, I also want to be able to use the printer in the loft from macs elsewhere in the house - though I think that might be a separate issue? (at the moment the children/wife have to email documents to me and then I print)

 

So, to recap:

  1. what 3g router will do now and keep me going if we get "proper" broadband?
  2. NAS - what sort, where to get from?  Needs to hold 600-700 cds plus more as I continue buying but I am not buying masses of new music (did buy 20 cds yesterday but they are the first purchase for nearly a year!)
  3. what software for the NAS to work with macs?  (have iphone/ipad for control)
  4. helpful basic guide to all this stuff anywhere?
  5. get the printer to work?

Sorry it's a long one!

Tim

Posted on: 29 September 2012 by Bart

I did some searching; how about something like a Netgear MBR 1515?  It looks to me to have the features of a traditional home wifi router, plus it accepts a SIM card and can access 3g and 4g mobile networks.  If you ever do get broadband internet access at your home, it looks like you could continue to use this.  If you are lucky, the "wireless n" wifi signal will be available thoughout your home.  You can experiment with moving it around your home to where it gets a good 3g signal and provides wifi where you want it.

 

Posted on: 29 September 2012 by Peter_RN

Hi Tim

 

Well, for a router I would look at the DrayTek range as many of these can use multiple broadband types including 3G and have wireless options if required.

 

As for a NAS I use Netgear ReadyNAS and Buffalo Linkstation (though Linkstation is quite old without usable UPnP server). Both have worked faultlessly, Qnap and Synology are also obvious contenders. If you intend to use the NAS’s  UPnP server to serve your music (as opposed to running through a computer) then this is probably the single most important issue to consider as the servers vary in the way they present your music for selection as generally but not always it is impossible to install an alternative server on a NAS. 700 CDs even in WAV format will easily fit in 500GB drive space, so in NAS terms this is quite small.

 

I have no knowledge of the Mac system so will leave that to others who will be able to advise, although most NAS run some form of Linux OS so should have no trouble in that respect.

 

I don’t know of a basic guide to suggest, but if you (or your girls) have reasonable computer skills these things are not that demanding to setup.

 

 As for your printer, if you are using wireless and wish to continue then there is no problem. But I would defiantly be looking to install wired especially for the Naim kit. Perhaps the router could be installed close to your main system or in the roof and a cable run to a switch (I assume that installing a lot of cables would be difficult for you) but Cat5e is not a lot bigger than a telephone cable and length is not a problem in a domestic environment. Remember you can install as many switches as you require so if you have a cluster of equipment close together a singe cable from the router to a switch is sometimes easier to install than multiple cables.

 

Hope this helps you get started, others will no doubt have other ideas.

 

Regards,

Peter

Posted on: 29 September 2012 by Bart

Tim, mac vs pc to set up and control the NAS is not an issue.  NAS's typically use a web interface for management and control.  So the NAS does not care if Firefox or Chrome or whatever browser is running on a mac or a pc.

 

As for your iPhone and iPad, you will use those to control playback by the UQ, but not to control the NAS; that is much better done from a computer.  But once things are set up, to play music stored on the nas you will not need to do anything to the NAS itself; the UQ does it all.

 

I highly recommend getting a printer with wifi built in.  Once you've got a wifi network in the house, it will be a simple matter to print from any computer on which you've "installed" that printer.  I would not spend money on a wifi adapter for an old printer if at all possible, and just buy a new one with wifi built in.  Setting those up on each computer is really easy these days.

Posted on: 29 September 2012 by AndyPat

I agree with Bart re getting a new 'in-built' wireless printer.Likely to be a stronger connection.

As for a NAS, it's something else to integrate. If you're Mac is sitting there idle I'd save money and use that. Most decent computers have eco settings that end up using not much more power than a NAS and you'll retain better integration for any other tasks if you stay all Apple.Apart from remote waking I don't really see the point in a separate NAS, though in fairness I probably do spend too much time with my computers.

 

Andy

Posted on: 30 September 2012 by living in lancs yearning for yorks

Thanks guys - though I still don't understand quite a bit it is helpful to have some of the options set out!

 

Re the wireless printer - it might be an option to get a family printer that is wireless but the current printer is a colour HP laser printer (£300 ish I think excluding ink) that is still working perfectly well so it would be lunacy to replace...

 

Maybe the best thing is to use the iMac, as suggested by Andy, for now - will do some research into how I can do that sensibly, though I will now have to stop telling the family to turn it off after they have used it... have been spending the last few months trying to persuade them not to leave lights, computers etc on so seems like defeat to stop doing that! 

 

There have been a number of other guides referred to in this forum in the last couple of days that I have found since I made my first post above so will read them - though I do have a growing sense of doom from the extra complexity that can arise from streaming - more to go wrong.  And being in the country we have several power cuts a year

Posted on: 30 September 2012 by Bart

Perhaps just to get started in the world of digital music you should play files from a usb stick or an iPod directly into the UQ?  You could rip your cd's into one of the compatible Apple lossless formats and put them on an iPod.  If/when you move into networked music, those files would be just fine to stream to your UQ.

Posted on: 30 September 2012 by PinkHamster
Originally Posted by Bart:

Perhaps just to get started in the world of digital music you should play files from a usb stick or an iPod directly into the UQ?  You could rip your cd's into one of the compatible Apple lossless formats and put them on an iPod.  If/when you move into networked music, those files would be just fine to stream to your UQ.

No, No, No!!! Apple will not convey the structure, which is necessary for a real digital streaming environmemt. Stay PC. Get a QNAP or NetGear or ReadyNAS or whatever and simply start. Don't worry, you'll get the hang of it. Just get started.

Posted on: 30 September 2012 by Bart
Originally Posted by PinkHamster:
Originally Posted by Bart:

Perhaps just to get started in the world of digital music you should play files from a usb stick or an iPod directly into the UQ?  You could rip your cd's into one of the compatible Apple lossless formats and put them on an iPod.  If/when you move into networked music, those files would be just fine to stream to your UQ.

No, No, No!!! Apple will not convey the structure, which is necessary for a real digital streaming environmemt. Stay PC. Get a QNAP or NetGear or ReadyNAS or whatever and simply start. Don't worry, you'll get the hang of it. Just get started.

 

Given where the OP is starting, with NO home network at the moment, wired or wireless, imho telling him to buy a NAS and "simply start" is not good advice to get him using the UQ right away.  Yes, to create a home music library that can be played from a future NDS in the parlor and the UQ dictates that eventually he'll want a NAS and a robust home network.  One step at a time . . .

Posted on: 01 October 2012 by living in lancs yearning for yorks

Blimey - geeks arguing over the advice.  Am this morning working downstairs with the main system playing so I don't need to worry about getting the UQ fully functioning yet.  

 

I have helpfully had some offline advice from fixedwheel who understands this sort of thing, and am keen to launch into QNAP though need to do a bit of looking round to get sorted what to buy and how to get up and running.  I do appreciate the cautionary approach of finding a simple way to start but I can see that that would cost me more in the long run, and if I don't grasp the NAS-nettle now I may never get round to doing it - probably best to start now while I don't have NDS so that when I go for one I should be able to dive in more quickly.  As a Yorkshire born accountant I am keen to take a longer view and spend my pounds wisely 

Posted on: 01 October 2012 by thebiglebowski

A QNAP NAS TS-212 is a great option for you as it will work as a print server so you can access the printer from anywhere on your home network and also has squeezebox server as a qpkg application (you can read up on qpkg later so don't worry about the name for now)

 

WiFi routers these days have very good range but if the stone wall is still an issue have a look at some powerlines for your kids bedrooms. Try and plan out your network on paper before buying anything and if possible have the NAS and Qute on a wired LAN and then let everyone else connect in via wireless.

Posted on: 01 October 2012 by Bart

Some offline advice, and maybe even a mate to come by and help you with it, is ideal.  Surely you can do it, it's just a matter of what resources you have available to you as you work it out.  And your personal tolerance for frustration vs. the prospect of learning something new. Once it's up and running you'll enjoy it, and be glad you learned.

 

Start with the network itself, then the attached storage (NAS).  A NAS with no network isn't all that useful

Posted on: 01 October 2012 by living in lancs yearning for yorks

Bart, a NAS without a network is just an as(s)

 

I do have a good local friend who would undoubtedly help with setup (he's helped with the nVi) - he's just a nightmare to ask questions since he answers too completely...