Almost ridiculous difference
Posted by: Jonas Olofsson on 05 October 2013
This upgrade surpriced me a lot. Less harsh, better bass and the whole sound is a lot fuller. Never easy to describe this kind of stuff in words but there is really no contest.
I guess this is common sense for most here that everything makes a difference, still I wasent preparerad how much better it would be.
Yes, its a capable system I use but at this level everything seams be important.
//Jonas
Hey ho, time for a bunny or two.
This one's for Jason.
Don't worry Tog, you get one too :
umbridge
that's the third left after Knightsbridge ?
Go wireless, it's cheaper.
and, according to a Naim insider, it can sound better too, since it electrically decouples the source and the player...
Well, yes, but now you have a RF receiver right there next to your player. Wouldn't it be "noisy"?
Not if it's kept in it's own shielded 'quiet room'. Isn't this what is done in the streamers (e.g., NDS) to prevent the RF signal from contaminating sensitive electronics ? (shielded section on left side of image)
Placebo works wonders in many cases.
I can understand how electric currents in speaker cable can be affected by capacitance and resistance, but I don't understand how it is the case with bits. Can it cause jitter?
Jan: Thanks for the Bunnies. Tog: Thanks for "Year of the Cat". I SO prefer the dust-ups on the Forum among distinguished members to the cat-fights on (un)-reality-TV. Considering killing Cable for good; and I may just buy a Qute, or summut, due to the occasion.
Cheers,
Nick
The placebo effect and cognitive bias both clearly exist and are danger for any upgrade. One of the reasons I like Naim gear is the upgrade path reduces their impact (because a Supercap is better than a Hicap, right?).
However, simply saying that you don't think these cables work and that the placebo effect definitely exists so that proves you are right, is not enough.
I would just urge you to try them and tell us if you still think it's an illusion.
Keith
umbridge
That's what radio is for an every day story of HiFi folk?
The placebo effect and cognitive bias both clearly exist and are danger for any upgrade. One of the reasons I like Naim gear is the upgrade path reduces their impact (because a Supercap is better than a Hicap, right?).
However, simply saying that you don't think these cables work and that the placebo effect definitely exists so that proves you are right, is not enough.
I would just urge you to try them and tell us if you still think it's an illusion.
Keith
But its like urging me to travel to the moon to check there is not a red london bus there, because I cannot prove until such time that there is not.
There is no logic to the last metre of ethernet cable at 600 quid making any difference beyond being well constructed. If it has to be shielded etc, great, as simon says they can be picked up at excellent quality for a tenner. This is data we are talking about. Its hardly subjective. If you can hear sound without blips, or silence then its working.
My logic dictates that I would ensure that my network is second to none. For an addition 600 quid I could ensure that I have the industry leading router, switch or professional install of ethernet around the house, with good quality industry standard ethernet sockets.
Or I might direct my money to faster spinning harddrives for my NAS, or a superior NAS, or or or.
Now assuming the OP has all this in place, industry leading router and switch, professional installed ethernet and quality sockets where necessery and he has money to spend, heck fill your boots, 600 quid for an ethernet cable, happy days.
If however he is using a BT homehub with that 600 quid cable, I laugh, heartily.
I wonder if he would recommend 600 quid a metre ethernet cable throughout the house?
I would like to put my new audiophile cabling firm "TogTec" forward as the contractor for that job - shortly before I buy myself an island. I'm also developing a new ethernet cable that uses Quantum Foam theory to bind multiple coils of platinum around a core made of pure Togtanium (patent pending) - price on application - I call it the Absinthe Surprise ethernet cable.
Tog
Tog...I know your favourite past time is peeing on the furniture, so maybe we should start a new thread called the 'litter tray' where you can show disdain to your hearts content.
Jason - interesting response - on the one hand there are a number of people who take instant umbridge whenever anyone disagrees with their views - however gently and on the other people who seemingly feel insulted if you fail to be absolutely serious. So let us set out our stall to avoid further misunderstanding.
1. I humbly choose to disagree with the argument that spending £600 on an ethernet cable is really going to make much difference to the sound.
2. I am not suprised or dismayed by the fact that there are those who disagree with me as that is one of the joys of both life and conversation.
3. In my experience there are only a few things in life that sould be taken totally seriously and take my word for it - hifi isn't one of them.
4. I note with interest that the very people who complain about dogmatism in this forum are coincidentally those most likely to get very upset and leave a thread when others disagree with them.
5. Some contributors to this thread have used their knowledge of electronics to question the scientific reasons why some people may experience differences between very similar cables. To me this seems less like dogmatism and more like intelligent argument but hey what do I know. Unfortunately, I inadvertently tried a more serious approach as a practising Social rather than Natural Scientist by suggested in all seriousness that the differences in sound quality might be explained by the perfectly respectable theory known as "Cognitive Bias". This was obviously a big mistake as it seems some people got confused and thought I was suggesting they were in fact lying when they heard a difference between ethernet cables. Easy mistake to make and that Nobel prize commitee really needs to take more care in future.
6. Finally, if you are going to attempt a convincing put-down try getting your facts right; cats pee on furniture to mark their territory not to show disdain for those around them. I know I know callous adherence to rationality but I'm a sucker for it.
7. If I'm hell bent on seeking only someone who will agree with me I've always found the bathroom mirror a good place to start.
Tog
PS My school reports did allude to a degree of annoying flippancy if it helps.
Hi Tog,
I read your posts and they are not as innocent as you make them out to be, just lots of justification for being sarcastic and rude and going by the last two posts, tedium seemed to have got the better of you, so I thought I would join in with some of your flippancy.
It turned out quite well as it inspired the 'LitterTray' thread which I thought would be a good idea. but perhaps it's not for you after all.
The natural instinct maybe to 'mark territories' but the material affect is disdain for the furniture...which according to my thinking, fits well here.
Jason.
Blimey, Jason a post that misses the point, deftly avoids dealing with the issues and yet still manages to mangle a childish insult with a complete disregard for logic - you really don't like people who disagree with you do you?
How can the material effect (please get it right) of a cat peeing on furniture imply that the cat is showing contempt or a lack of respect for the furniture whilst marking his territory. Since a cat is unlikely to have much of a conceptual grasp of either furniture or human emotions.
As for the litter tray it's nice to know that whilst my attempts at light-heartedness are sarastic and rude your chosen metaphor is both wholesome and witty.
If you are going to be rude at my expense at least do me the decency of making sense.
4/10
Tog
Tog – I am fully aware of its textbook inaccuracy.
In the context of a flippant remark, debating its accuracy is just another attempt to detract from my main point. And where in my posts do I come across as someone who hates to be wrong? I really think that you should review your last response to me.
Back to the point, having said that you have not heard these interconnects you continuously ridiculed and showed disdain toward the OP and his findings, even after the OP had declared himself thoroughly fed up with yours and other Forum members arrogant remarks toward him, and even after he left the bar. It does not matter how much you or anyone else attempt to dress these comments up with social science rational (who are you trying to kid), the lack of respect is very clear. And your continual assertion that your comments are meant with humour does not stand up, when on the one hand you attempt flippant and whimsy comments, then on the other debate accuracy to justify your poor attempt to hide disdain.
It really is that simple Tog.
Jason.
If a Forum member posts with what he feels to be a relevant piece of information, and his intentions are honest and sincere, yet he is met with arrogant and rude responses, then why should he bother to post anything?
Surely, to keep the Forum rolling posters should be met with honest debate not ridicule.
Jason.
If a Forum member posts with what he feels to be a relevant piece of information, and his intentions are honest and sincere, yet he is met with arrogant and rude responses, then why should he bother to post anything?
Surely, to keep the Forum rolling posters should be met with honest debate not ridicule.
Jason.
JAson. I think you expect everyone to be the same as you or something?
This is a forum. By its name its a place for open discussions where many personailities and opinions will come out.
For instance the OP believes he heard a massive difference with a 600 quid ethernet cable.
I thought that was hilarious.
Tog has made suggestions for other reasons he may have heard a difference
You are not happy about that
Simon as usual is being perfectly reasonable.
etc etc. Its what makes it interesting. If you want a forum where we all just stroke each others egos, then may I suggest you avoid, hifi/computer/gaming/motor forums.
Analysing... he doesn't seem too worried though.
Great photo. Is this a new form of heat sync?
You also often see pre loved kit or sale from smoke and pet free homes !! Not the case here !!
Whats new pussycat. Woo a hoo a
If a Forum member posts with what he feels to be a relevant piece of information, and his intentions are honest and sincere, yet he is met with arrogant and rude responses, then why should he bother to post anything?
Surely, to keep the Forum rolling posters should be met with honest debate not ridicule.
Jason.
This is a forum. By its name its a place for open discussions where many personailities and opinions will come out.
For instance the OP believes he heard a massive difference with a 600 quid ethernet cable.
I thought that was hilarious.
Tog has made suggestions for other reasons he may have heard a difference
You are not happy about that
Simon as usual is being perfectly reasonable.
etc etc. Its what makes it interesting. If you want a forum where we all just stroke each others egos, then may I suggest you avoid, hifi/computer/gaming/motor forums.
Gary,
I think you may find that most of my posts here on the Forum do not indicate that I favour a consensus view on anything particularly...well perhaps the U-Serve. So I stand by my previous post.
My "unhappiness" derives from the agenda boys, who go about ridiculing other Forum members when they simply don't agree with him. Any meaningful debate on this particular thread arrived post ridicule and when this was pointed out.
As I said, its not difficult to understand and is a common sentiment.
Jason.
Its should be noted I don't have an agenda, I am just an arse.
As long as we have the distinction, I am happy enough.
Instead of argument and/or contradiction, why not a few groups of 'local' naimees join for a listening test (rather than alone in own home / dealer hovering behind you in shop). The group of selfless individuals could be known as the 'distributed disciples of debunking'.
Publish and be damned!
The tests could relate to ANY hot topic:
3 to get you all going: Ethernet cables; Supernait2 and a bag of nails; NAC 172 XS + any power amp. vs. the carton my SU came in (not fair to pit it against the SU).
Analysing... he doesn't seem too worried though.
Great photo. Is this a new form of heat sync?
You also often see pre loved kit or sale from smoke and pet free homes !! Not the case here !!
Whats new pussycat. Woo a hoo a
Just for the record - I use Cat 5
Tog
Great picture - I'm sure he loves that cosy warm spot on the Uniti.
Hers's the thing...
Years ago when I was first given a loan Uniti to demo at home by my dealer he supplied it with two metres of Altas Mavros cable.
As you can see, even as a kitten, one of my cats fell in love with not just the Naim sound but also its gentle warmth. He now spends most nights in the winter luxuriating on my Nap 200 and has made it clear that upgrading to a class D powered Devialet or Linn KDS is out of the question.
I have no idea if the Mavros speaker cable really made much of a difference to the sound quality but given that it would have cost me almost as much to buy as the Uniti I didn't lose much sleep when I changed to very good quality but slightly more reasonable Atlas product. However, the Mavros looked fantastic, was thicker than my thumb and was clearly made of exotic materials only found on the surface of passing comets - massive overkill for the Uniti but truly lovely shiny stuff.
I have no problem with the concept of good quality speaker cable having a tangible impact on sound quality. However, I'm also aware of the fact that had I spent £1900 on the Mavros my ears would have been heavily influenced in terms of justifying both the huge dent in my wallet and Mrs Tog's displeasure.
If I told you that my Naim gear sounds better at night, especially if it raining: would you believe me? Well to my ears it does. The effect is even more noticeable if I am in a good mood, drinking wine or if work has gone well during the day.
I suspect it might even sound better with a cat on top than without!
My point is this: I think much of what we hear is affected not only by the electronics but by what is going on between our ears.
Tog
My cats seem to beat a hasty retreat as soon as I put the music on... Feedback on my musical tastes I suspect...
Never tried one as an acoustic damper on the NDS either.
(part 2)
And to think I smiled at that picture. But cats make me smile. I like cats. I can massage them into total submission and a state of paralysis-inducing grace, though I do stop before respiratory arrest. However, the larger issue is the fact that I'm writing about it here instead of about the Supernait2 (deadline approaching). I know exactly what I want to say, but haven't found the words yet.
So a huge and hearty thanks guys, for reminding me again of how important time is.* At 58 it's a diminishing commodity (but one the Supernait2 handles quite magnificently).
Peace, as we used to say,
J-E
* and allowing me to practice here.
What I find dishonest and misleading is that Audioquest describe these cables as 'Digital-Audio Cables' when in fact they have nothing to do with audio what-so-ever. Ethernet cables carry data from one place to another not audio. The audio is reconstructed INSIDE your streamer.
Changing ethernet cables CANNOT have any effect on the sound - seriously, it is not scientifically possible for that to happen. This is snake oil.
Being able to hear a difference between two different ethernet cables (that are conformant to the specification) is like saying you hear a differences in the sound quality of your system depending on who goes to the CD rack, picks the CD and carries it to the player. Would you say you music sounds different if you or a friend does this? Of course not, you know thats silly, and what you have to understand is, that this is what an ethernet cable does; it carries the CD (digital data) from the CD rack (your server) to the player (your streamer) and it CANNOT affect the sound quality.
Audioquest are playing on peoples lack of understanding of the difference between a digital data cable and an analog audio cable.