10 Best Protest Songs Of All Time - Rolling Stone Magazine.

Posted by: Steve J on 07 December 2014

Only the other week whilst listening to Masters of War on Bob Dylan's Freewheelin' I commented to fellow forum member Tony Miller that this was, for me, the best Protest Song ever written. It would appear others think likewise as can be seen in this Rolling Stone Poll.

 

http://www.rollingstone.com/mu...of-all-time-20141203

Posted on: 07 December 2014 by Big Bill
Originally Posted by Frenchnaim:

the best Protest Song ever written

...in English.

and it's 2,3,4 what are we fighting for?

Posted on: 08 December 2014 by Frenchnaim

Boris Vian's 1954 protest song "Le déserteur" (The deserter) must be a classic example of the genre - written at the end of the Indochina War., sung later by Joan Baez and others.

Posted on: 08 December 2014 by Gale 501

Surprised Tom Paxton didn't turn up on that RS list?

He has written some brilliant protest songs over the years.

Posted on: 08 December 2014 by Big Bill
Originally Posted by Gale 501:

Surprised Tom Paxton didn't turn up on that RS list?

He has written some brilliant protest songs over the years.

Indeed Gale and Pete Seeger has not been mentioned yet - btw did he ever find those flowers?

Posted on: 08 December 2014 by David O'Higgins

I would have 'My Country tis of thy people you're dying' by Buffy St. Marie and 'Children of Fear' by Tucker Zimmerman:

 

we were the children of this god
we stood by heaven’s gates
our nation’s scattered to the wind
these Disunited States

 

we were living in your cities
it’s put us out of touch
oh America, you eat your children
that’s asking much too much too much

 

Check out the track on Youtube. Tucker deserved much more success than he had.

Posted on: 08 December 2014 by Gale 501

Lots of great women artists not getting a mention.

Posted on: 08 December 2014 by Big Bill
Originally Posted by Gale 501:

Lots of great women artists not getting a mention.

Yes David mentioned Buffy St. Marie, who also wrote "The Universal Soldier" the song that Donavon had such a big hit with.  Joni wrote "Woodstock" and mentions "the bomber death planes turning into butterflies across our nation" - that has a resonance to an aging stoned-out hippie I can tell you.

Another Canadian woman is K.D. Lang - great voice (just love to hear her sing) and writer but can't remember any protest songs from her.

Nancy Griffith's wrote one or two and covered some greats from other writers:

From a Distance - Julie Gold.

One of the most beautiful songs I have ever heard is "Deadwood, South Dakota", written by Eric Taylor.  Not so much an anti war song, more anti-genocide/anti-white supremacist song.  If you have never heard Nancy sing this song then you really should, it is stunning.

Posted on: 08 December 2014 by tonym

Not forgetting the wonderful Joan Baez of course!

Posted on: 08 December 2014 by Gale 501
Originally Posted by Big Bill:
Originally Posted by Gale 501:

Lots of great women artists not getting a mention.

Yes David mentioned Buffy St. Marie, who also wrote "The Universal Soldier" the song that Donavon had such a big hit with.  Joni wrote "Woodstock" and mentions "the bomber death planes turning into butterflies across our nation" - that has a resonance to an aging stoned-out hippie I can tell you.

Another Canadian woman is K.D. Lang - great voice (just love to hear her sing) and writer but can't remember any protest songs from her.

Nancy Griffith's wrote one or two and covered some greats from other writers:

From a Distance - Julie Gold.

One of the most beautiful songs I have ever heard is "Deadwood, South Dakota", written by Eric Taylor.  Not so much an anti war song, more anti-genocide/anti-white supremacist song.  If you have never heard Nancy sing this song then you really should, it is stunning.

Buffy,

Was one of the very first artists to record a album at home and send it down a phone line to a record company to press and release.

Posted on: 08 December 2014 by winkyincanada
Originally Posted by nickpeacock:

Terribly English I know, but I do like 'Ideologies' by Billy Bragg...

Yes, a classic.