Getting The Best From ATC SCM11s

Posted by: nj451 on 13 September 2016

Hi all,

My system is a RP6, Uniti2, SCM11v2 and NACA5

The speakers while good at low levels are a bit lacking in the bass department- everything else is there, it's just that I'd like a bit more bass presence for a more balanced sound. On the other end of the scale, pushing the volume past 60% on the U2, the SCM11s start to lose resolution. This kind of volume is above my usual listening level, but you know how it is: when you hear a good tune, you just wanna turn it up!

Speakers are about 30cm from the rear wall, toed in so that the cones are pointing to the seating position.

First and foremost, are the speakers in the right place? I know Simon has his 19s at 50cm, but is the toe-in correct? The soundstage does not appear to be that wide for me, with vocals coming from dead center of the speakers (right above the boxes).

Next, how to fill out the bass detail at lower volumes, and increase resolution at higher volumes. I'm aware that these tricky to drive, heavy speakers are closed-box design, so I am never going to get thunderous, chest pounding bass from them.

The way I see it, I have three options:

NAP200/250 (a possibility since one day I might upgrade to a 172/272

ATC C1 Sub

ATC SCM19v2

Not looking to change the speakers (unless they're the 19s). If someone could provide some quick info on what each of my proposed upgrades would do to my system, I'd really appreciate it. 

Also, if there other other options I have not considered, please feel free

Thanks,

Neil

Posted on: 13 September 2016 by Halloween Man

the more you toe them in the more top end you will hear so try firing them so that they point well behind the listening position and see if that improves matters. also the closer to the rear and side walls the more bass. id say 6 foot apart, firing behind the listening position, and 1-2 foot from side and rear walls (keep side and rear wall distance different if u can) would be a good place to start. listening 6-8 foot away from speakers.

you do have another option, scm19a or scm40a active speakers (do not require power amp).

Posted on: 13 September 2016 by Huge

We need more information to provide you with meaningful advice...

What size and shape is your room?

Are you prepared to consider using any form of digital room correction?

Which is your balance of priorities: Which is most important to you, more bass or more resolution?
The different solutions will balance these differently.

Posted on: 13 September 2016 by hungryhalibut

Try them pointing straight ahead. Then toe them in just enough to get a stable central image on vocals. You'll get a much bigger, more open sound, which will hopefully give you what you are looking for. 

Posted on: 13 September 2016 by likesmusic

ATC recommend listening to all their speakers on-axis and with the tweeter (or midrange if there is one) at or a little above ear height, and about as far away from the speakers as they are apart, so I would start there. Having them out from the walls makes sense. Move around the room, and closer or further away from the speakers, to see whether you are sitting in a bass null. A single voice should (usually) sound dead centre and relatively narrow - this indicates a good speaker, without any phase issues.  Nothing like a decent amount of power though. If you are tempted to go up the range  hold your horses until you've heard the active SCM19s .. might as well do the job properly

Posted on: 13 September 2016 by Klyde

My SCM11's are about 30cms from wall, the sound is bass light. They are on a monitor shelf, on my "Studio" desk, they are toed in, so that the "inside" surfaces of the baffle are visible. The stereo image from swivel chair, is superb. Better than the image from SCM40's in the lounge (very difficult room). I'm going to gradually slide the 11's back, in an attempt to bring the bass up a little.

Distance from wall for 3 pairs of ATC speakers in our house -

SCM 7's - 5cm "depth of wall brackets"

SCM11's - 30cm, think about 10-15cm should do it.

SCM40's - 60cm, as per ATC's recommendation, bass is plentiful, tight, and tuneful. Shame re " slight hole in middle sound stage" due to large distance between speakers, but I had to live with this, with last 2 pairs of speakers due to room layout.

I tried my 250 into SCM11's, on stands, result was the chest pounding bass, with greater control.

As Huge said, more info, re your room would help.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Posted on: 13 September 2016 by Simon-in-Suffolk

Hi Neil, i think with the ATC sealed cabinets - its less about closeness to walls for bass - but more about stands and height. I have found higher mass stands reinforce bass sometimes overly so  - but treble performance falls off in terms of clarity. I find light rigid stands about 60cms tall sound best across the frequency range and resolves micro transients and details the best - albeit with the 19s. I find the closer to the walls you take the ATCs - bass doesn't necessarily increase but imaging and dynamics  seem to lessen - perhaps more refraction form the wall..

You might find you have some room cancellations - and so you might find the bass comes and goes depending where you sit - because the ATCs are relatively so neutral across the frequency band this sort of room effect can become more apparent than ported speaker with a bass enhancement boost.

Posted on: 13 September 2016 by nj451

Thanks for the responses so far. I'll try to fill in the blanks.

Room is 17' x 11.5' and the speakers are firing down the width of the room, at least 4' either side of the side walls. I have the speakers over 8' apart, with the seated position the same distance to form an equilateral triangle. They're on Altacama SE24s 25" high which puts the tweeters at ear height. Stands not filled yet.

I know nothing on the digital correction front, so I'll say no for now.

And if I were to have to choose between more bass at lower volumes and better resolution at higher levels, as a former clubber with damaged hearing I'd have to go for better resolution, so long as the bass is unaffected.

Simon - The treble is fine, very good in fact...I just want a bit more control at higher levels

I'll certainly give toeing the speakers to just behind the listening position and fill the speaker stands to see if there's an improvement.

Again, thanks

Neil

Posted on: 14 September 2016 by Simon-in-Suffolk

Hi Neil - although I have just a given several speaker stand sets away to charity - I have played around with many stand types over the years with the ATC entry series speakers (the 12, 11 and 19). Light open rigid like Russ Andrews or Something Solid appear to give the best balance - although special care is needed between speaker and stand. I use Pulsar Point decouplers.

Stands designed to be mass filled should be - although you can 'tune' them with the amount you fill. I have found typically around 60% optimal to provide weight and reduce (although not to the extent of open rigid stands) treble/mid smearing through ringing (will remove very fine detail and atmospheric realism - get a 252 or 552 and you will almost definitely notice this). Therefore I strongly suggest you fill you stands to increase bass (and physical) weight. I have previously used filled Atacama SL series stands - great for parties with bass weight - but not great at subtlety for the reasons I guess I outline above... Also if you talk to ATC they suggest for their  two way speakers that optimum height should be such that the point between the treble and bass/mid drivers is in line with your ears and not the tweeter... though I doubt it makes a huge difference.....

Simon