Salewa Alp trainer mid GTX walking boots 'schlurping' noise

Posted by: Loki on 30 December 2016

Father Xmas delivered a spectacular pair of Salewa Mid Trainer approach-style walking boots. They are the most impressively comfortable boots I've ever owned and are great for general roving the universe duties. They look cool too. However, with every step they make a kind of 'slurp-flop' sound like a low level squelch as the air inside the boot moves with each step. I have never, ever, had this issue before with any pair of boots. Do you have any idea what may be causing it? and if so, short of sending them back, how to cure it? I've tried a different insole and lacing tighter/more relaxedly, to no avail. Norse gods shouldn't 'schlurp'. It takes the edge off the role, and sneaking up on unsuspecting mortals is rendered impossible.

Posted on: 30 December 2016 by TOBYJUG

Perhaps if you could give more details. Size of feet in girth and Length and rise of arch. It could be possible to calculate the best fit.

boots are the most difficult part of ones attire to get right. In putting together an outfit that is suitable for a situation you should focus on the source.

if it's raining and wet you don't wear suede.

if it's icy don't wear leather soled 

if it's cold don't wear plimsolls 

if indoors, take them off

If at any time you experience the situation when your heels are coming out and up from the shoe, and you find that your socks have turned 180 degrees from whence they were put on - then this is called a NIGHTMARE. Best course of action in this situation is to sit down.

Posted on: 31 December 2016 by Loki

Tres drole TJ 

Posted on: 31 December 2016 by Christopher_M

TJ is a drole sole

C.

Posted on: 31 December 2016 by Mike-B

The droll soul TJ should not be confused with the TJ who lives under a workbench in a backroom in Salisbury.   

Posted on: 31 December 2016 by Steve2

I had a pair of boxer shorts that used to do that.  I had to get rid of them in the end as they were so embarrassing to wear in public.

Posted on: 31 December 2016 by Gianluigi Mazzorana

I think is the membranes that allow air to go in and out from the boot and that keep foot dry.

The 2 Scarpa boots models i own work the same way. I think that after few hours of use you'll not hear that noise anymore. At least in open enviroment.

Posted on: 31 December 2016 by ChrisSU
Gianluigi Mazzorana posted:

I think is the membranes that allow air to go in and out from the boot and that keep foot dry.

The 2 Scarpa boots models i own work the same way. I think that after few hours of use you'll not hear that noise anymore. At least in open enviroment.

.....in which case the noise will more than likely stop when the friction that caused it wears a hole in the waterproof Goretex liner.

Posted on: 31 December 2016 by Gianluigi Mazzorana

Air gets pushed out when you push down the foot inside the boot creating a kind of vacuum and get sucked in when you lift  your foot and pressure on the insole gets lower.

Membranes are usually located not in contact with goretex and do not have a direct way out or when you walk in water or melting snow you get wet.

It's a pump. But it's made of rubber. So that's the noise when they are new.

Posted on: 31 December 2016 by ChrisSU
Gianluigi Mazzorana posted:

Membranes are usually located not in contact with goretex and do not have a direct way out or when you walk in water or melting snow you get wet.

Perhaps we are talking at cross purposes here, the membrane I'm talking about is Goretex.

Posted on: 31 December 2016 by Gianluigi Mazzorana

And my english can't take me too far!

Anyway i think that after few hours of use noise will get softer! Or one could sing some Alpenjager songs while walking!

To cover the "schlurp" i mean

Posted on: 01 January 2017 by Loki

'Valderi, valdera, valderi vader- ha ha ha ha ha ha, ha...'

Gianluigi maybe on to something. Prepare for the Goretex cycle as sung to the tune of the Happy Wanderer.

I'll put them through their paces in Kernow this week and let you know.

Posted on: 04 January 2017 by Bart
TOBYJUG posted:

If at any time you experience the situation when your heels are coming out and up from the shoe, and you find that your socks have turned 180 degrees from whence they were put on - then this is called a NIGHTMARE. Best course of action in this situation is to sit down.

I suffer this NIGHTMARE with probably 20% of the shoes/boots I purchase.  I think it's because I'm "between sizes" and it's hard for me to get a good fit.

Posted on: 04 January 2017 by sjbabbey

Ging heut morgen übers feld?

Posted on: 06 January 2017 by Loki

Still schlurping...still annoying, still comfortable.

Posted on: 20 January 2017 by Loki

Partial success. Epiphany moment when adjusting the lacing. Tight at the toe tip, loose across the broadest part of the foot. Tight at the ankle and then a more relaxed fit on the cleats up the ankle. Much quieter. It had gotten to the stage where passers by were looking to see where the noise was coming from!