Speakers home test > hmmm....

Posted by: Adam Zielinski on 24 November 2017

Starting a longish journey. Somewhat inspired by the recent offering at the Warsaw Audioshow 2017.
A highlight of a show for me was a demo of Hegel boxes powering a set of rather impressive Trenner & Friedl 'Taliesin' speakers. That was just pure music - who cares about the boxes if they produce such magic
They only have one small 'problem' - a pair retails for nearly EUR 80k.. 

Back to reality....

First set arrived home today, delivered and set up by my long-suffering dealer. I suspect he will be making several trips with various boxes over the next months...

First in the line of fire.. 
Monitor Audio Platinum 300II - they had some rave reviews and I'm partial to Monitor Audio offerings (currently using MA Gold 300s). 

First impressions..... hmmm....  probably not helped by a fact that the local distributor delivered a demo pair, which I suspect was never really used.
So again - a home demo on un-run speakers. Painful....

My wife just looked at me, shrugged her shoulders and said - 'they are not run in, they sound horrible, and once one has heard Taliesins nothing sounds good...'
One thing must be said though - an absolutely superb finish and they look stunning in piano black, with fronts covered in black leather.

Partnering electronics: NDX + 555PS, SN2 + HiCap DR + NAP 250 DR, SuperLumina full loom.
I know, I know - SN2 as a pre is holding me back, NDX is rubbish without a Hugo, etc, etc. But it is what it is at the moment 

So is there a question in this post?
Not really... just a a bit of Friday-evening-frustration sharing with my fellow Forum friends.

To quote one forum member - "Enjoy The Music - The Why!"

Posted on: 24 November 2017 by Finkfan

Have fun Adam. Are there many speakers on your demo list? 

Posted on: 24 November 2017 by Adam Zielinski

Thanks Adam!

I'm demoing each set for 2 weeks. The next ones - Atohm GT3.

I'd love to try something from Trenner & Friedl, possibly Harbeth and ATC - but I'm afraid their designs are far too utilitarian to maintain domestic harmony.
I strongly dislike the look and sound of Focals - they made the Statement (runing with NDS + 555PSDR and Core) sound broken at the Audioshow.

So frustration is starting to creep in....

Posted on: 24 November 2017 by Finkfan

I have to admit I did drool over a pair of Magico’s at a recent show. The Wilson Alexia 2s also sounded fantastic. 

Posted on: 24 November 2017 by Mayor West

Surely a nice pair of PMC's would fit the bill for a domestic setting?

Posted on: 24 November 2017 by wenger2015

Hi Adam,

Sounds like your in for a lot of fun..... don’t dismiss the focals, the problem is they take a long long time to run in....most shows I’ve been too, apart from the occasional exception most speakers perform quite poorly, no doubt for similar reasons....

at one naim demo they Repeatedly said ‘ the boxes and speakers will sound far better in your home environment ‘ this is not a good room...

Anyway enjoy your home demo’s

Posted on: 24 November 2017 by themrock

Try the Dali Epicon 6, they sound tremendous and the look is stunning.

Posted on: 24 November 2017 by Hook

The only T&F speakers I’ve heard were the Pharoahs, and they were wonderful.  Can only imagine how fine the Taliesins sounded.  Good luck with your speaker auditions!

Posted on: 24 November 2017 by Adam Zielinski
Hook posted:

The only T&F speakers I’ve heard were the Pharoahs, and they were wonderful.  Can only imagine how fine the Taliesins sounded.  Good luck with your speaker auditions!

Very interesting .... I'm in contact with a distributor in Poland. I think I will set up an audition for several speakers...

Thanks for the tip.

Posted on: 24 November 2017 by No quarter

Adam,I always wanted to hear Trenner and Friedl Speakers,after reading glowing reviews,I still have the Art monos on my wish list of speakers I want to try.

Posted on: 24 November 2017 by badlands
Adam Zielinski posted:

Thanks Adam!

I'm demoing each set for 2 weeks. The next ones - Atohm GT3.

 

I have been praising these speakers for quite a long time on this forum, I predict they will be your next speaker.

Posted on: 24 November 2017 by Paristhea

Hi Adam, has been long time, how are you?

You may find the following link interesting: 

However, 10,000 Euro plus for a pair of speakers, would have to be accompanied by equipment of similar value, usually. 

Your preamp I think is fine, yes if could be bettered, but there again, everything could.  Unless you have a Turn Table, you don't know the real sound of an album.  What DAC do you use now?  Most of my music is streamed via N272 / 250DR, but unless I play my LP12 I don't feel fulfilled.  Don't know much about Chord products, but I don't rate the Hugo, for me it is nothing special.  Perhaps the Dave is the equivalent to an LP12 in a digital word.

P.S. I love the SL speaker cables by the way

Posted on: 24 November 2017 by Joppe

Adam, one speaker you might want to add to your list is Kef Reference, I heard ref 3 in a store demo. My impression from this was that they do somethings in the mid to high range a bit different to most other speakers in this price range, atleast they triggered my intrest. In the end I picked up a pair of used Magicos before any other auditions was started, so newer got around to any home auditions, but never the less they got my attention...

Posted on: 25 November 2017 by joerand

Adam,

Having recently heard Wilson Benesch Curves (a somewhat dated model) and knowing your love for the S-400s, I'd say give their brand a try, something from the (newer) Geometry series. The carbon fiber cabinets are impressive in looks and sound. Little resonant coloration with extreme clarity and resolution, tight bass and true yet never harsh treble. 

That said, I did find the vocals a tad on the dry side, maybe lacking some heft or coloration.

OTOH, you like the S-400s, so dry vocals might be just the ticket for you .

Posted on: 25 November 2017 by Adam Zielinski
Paristhea posted:

Hi Adam, has been long time, how are you?

You may find the following link interesting:

However, 10,000 Euro plus for a pair of speakers, would have to be accompanied by equipment of similar value, usually. 

Your preamp I think is fine, yes if could be bettered, but there again, everything could.  Unless you have a Turn Table, you don't know the real sound of an album.  What DAC do you use now?  Most of my music is streamed via N272 / 250DR, but unless I play my LP12 I don't feel fulfilled.  Don't know much about Chord products, but I don't rate the Hugo, for me it is nothing special.  Perhaps the Dave is the equivalent to an LP12 in a digital word.

P.S. I love the SL speaker cables by the way

This set of Naim boxes is paired with the follwig sources:

Digital: NDX + 555PS. I will most likely bring back my nDAC here.

Analogue: Rega RP10 with an Aphelion cartridge.

MAs are improving slowly....

Adam

PS That was one of the reviews that inspired me to test those speakers

Posted on: 25 November 2017 by Adam Zielinski
Joppe posted:

Adam, one speaker you might want to add to your list is Kef Reference, I heard ref 3 in a store demo. My impression from this was that they do somethings in the mid to high range a bit different to most other speakers in this price range, atleast they triggered my intrest. In the end I picked up a pair of used Magicos before any other auditions was started, so newer got around to any home auditions, but never the less they got my attention...

An interesting tip - KEF never made it to my radar screen. Thanks!

Posted on: 25 November 2017 by Adam Zielinski
joerand posted:

Adam,

Having recently heard Wilson Benesch Curves (a somewhat dated model) and knowing your love for the S-400s, I'd say give their brand a try, something from the (newer) Geometry series. The carbon fiber cabinets are impressive in looks and sound. Little resonant coloration with extreme clarity and resolution, tight bass and true yet never harsh treble. 

That said, I did find the vocals a tad on the dry side, maybe lacking some heft or coloration.

OTOH, you like the S-400s, so dry vocals might be just the ticket for you .

Joe- thak you! Beautiful speakers. I will give them a try...

Posted on: 25 November 2017 by Paristhea
Adam Zielinski posted:
Paristhea posted:

Hi Adam, has been long time, how are you?

You may find the following link interesting:

However, 10,000 Euro plus for a pair of speakers, would have to be accompanied by equipment of similar value, usually. 

Your preamp I think is fine, yes if could be bettered, but there again, everything could.  Unless you have a Turn Table, you don't know the real sound of an album.  What DAC do you use now?  Most of my music is streamed via N272 / 250DR, but unless I play my LP12 I don't feel fulfilled.  Don't know much about Chord products, but I don't rate the Hugo, for me it is nothing special.  Perhaps the Dave is the equivalent to an LP12 in a digital word.

P.S. I love the SL speaker cables by the way

This set of Naim boxes is paired with the follwig sources:

Digital: NDX + 555PS. I will most likely bring back my nDAC here.

Analogue: Rega RP10 with an Aphelion cartridge.

MAs are improving slowly....

Adam

PS That was one of the reviews that inspired me to test those speakers

Very good, so your Rega is your reference upon which you should make your decision, I would say.

And perhaps you should let the speakers stay at your place for at least a good two weeks (I would say a month really) with a run-in CD playing, if you can tolerate the noise, or something else playing.  They have to be a really good speakers I would think.

Personally I like the ProAC sound, it is music in my ears, for my style of music.  With Naim equipment it is a match made in heaven (for me)!!! 

Best regards,

 

Posted on: 25 November 2017 by Richard Dane

Could I remind members here that while discussion of various brands of loudspeaker is just fine, please do not post unauthorised links to either reviews or manufacturer websites.  Thanks.

Posted on: 25 November 2017 by Adam Zielinski

[@mention:45774755080751174]: indeed . For now I have another 50 hours of burning in to go - painful at times. Radio / NDX is on most of the time now just to get those beasts working.

Posted on: 25 November 2017 by yeti42

Do you have an aim for this system different from the other two? It doesn’t seem thet you’re just recycling componentas out of the best system to the second one and so on as you’re looking at a lot of speaker compared to the music room. Is there a flavour you’re looking for? (other than mullet)

I have my main system in my most comfortable room and it gets a lot of use, my system upstairs in the spare room I hardly ever use. I bought the speakers specifically for it but otherwise it’s components from 2 systems ago, my Core and DAC willl join it indue course. My setup in our place in France is my last main system minus the vinyl side, 555ps and the supercap, but they more or less fell into place not least because I hate selling stuff. 

 

Posted on: 25 November 2017 by Adam Zielinski

The living room is where the speakers are being auditioned. It’s much larger than my music room (40 sqm vs 18 sqm) so it can benefit from some large boxes.

The living room also houses our surround sound system - rear speakers are also floorstanders (Monitor Audio Gold 200s), and a centr channel us handled by a Monitor Audio Gold 350, powered by a Yamaha Aventage pre-power combo.

Naim handles the front L and R channels. At some stage my trusted SuperNait2 (which now runs with a HiCap DR and Nap 250DR)  may be replaced with a dedicated pre-amp. But I’m not in a hurry as I like the flexibility of connections and it doesn’t exactly sound ‘broken’ .

Sub is from Rel also in piano black.

So both the sound and aesthetics are important.

The test is a bit about checking if I really need to upgrade the speakers at all. Can I achieve a significant uplift in clarity or is it just not worth the hassle? I’m equally prepared to buy new speakers and to stay with what I have now - I was very clear and straight with my dealer before the process started.

 

Posted on: 25 November 2017 by The Strat (Fender)

Adam - do you have access to Neat, Kudos, Dynaudio, Harbeth?

Posted on: 25 November 2017 by nigelb

Adam, good luck with your speaker journey.

I thought I would let you know that my trusty Monitor Audio GX300s (as I know you have a pair) are sounding mighty fine this evening as I am trialling a 555DR on my NDS. I would be interested to hear how the MA Platinum 300IIs pan out.

Posted on: 25 November 2017 by Adam Zielinski
The Strat (Fender) posted:

Adam - do you have access to Neat, Kudos, Dynaudio, Harbeth?

My dealer can access Neat and Dynaudio quite easily - which models would you recommend I try?

Kudos and Harbeth have a bit of a challenging distribution - available, but I would have to go via a completely unknown (to me) dealer. 

Posted on: 25 November 2017 by Adam Zielinski
nigelb posted:

Adam, good luck with your speaker journey.

I thought I would let you know that my trusty Monitor Audio GX300s (as I know you have a pair) are sounding mighty fine this evening as I am trialling a 555DR on my NDS. I would be interested to hear how the MA Platinum 300IIs pan out.

Certainly Nigel. I even mounted the Vertere links on the Platinum 300IIs