Moving from Nova to classic series

Posted by: Popeye on 11 January 2018

Hi all

Having experienced many issues since owning a new Nova my dealership is giving me a refund as I have had 2 faulty Novas in the past 3 weeks. I have therefore lost faith in the unit and appreciate there will be 1000's of satisfied customers with no issues. Just my luck.

Anyway, my options now seem to be looking at pre-owned as I simply can't afford classic Naim new. I am going to have to put my hand in my pocket further but two setups which look like options are NDX,202,200 (non dr) or 272/250 Dr.

Can anyone shed any advise?

Many Thanks 

Popeye

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by hungryhalibut

There are literally thousands of posts on this, and no clear conclusion. It’s well worth searching the Forum. For what it’s worth, having owned a 202/200 in the past, I found it distinctly underwhelming without a napsc and Hicap, but very good with them. It’s ultimately a more flexible route, if that’s what you want. The NDX/Supernait 2 is another option well worth considering. 

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by Popeye
Hungryhalibut posted:

There are literally thousands of posts on this, and no clear conclusion. It’s well worth searching the Forum. For what it’s worth, having owned a 202/200 in the past, I found it distinctly underwhelming without a napsc and Hicap, but very good with them. It’s ultimately a more flexible route, if that’s what you want. The NDX/Supernait 2 is another option well worth considering. 

yes sorry, i will do a search. thanks for your advise tho.

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by Robert Burgess

One vote for a "pre-loved" 272/250DR. Great value!

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by hungryhalibut
Popeye posted:
Hungryhalibut posted:

There are literally thousands of posts on this, and no clear conclusion. It’s well worth searching the Forum. For what it’s worth, having owned a 202/200 in the past, I found it distinctly underwhelming without a napsc and Hicap, but very good with them. It’s ultimately a more flexible route, if that’s what you want. The NDX/Supernait 2 is another option well worth considering. 

yes sorry, i will do a search. thanks for your advise tho.

Please don’t apologise. I was simply suggesting that a search might help you. It’s something of a minefield. 

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by No quarter

272/250 DR is fantastic,I have not heard the 202/200,I will also add,that I have never had a problem with my 272/250 working properly.

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by ChrisSU

When I bought my current system, I spent quite a bit of time at my dealers listening to those two setups. For me, the NDX/202/200 was a very clear winner, and the 272 was only able to complete when it had an XPS added. 

To be fair to the 272/250, at no point did I dislike it, and if your speakers are hard to drive, the 250 may be a better option. Also, the 272 has a better volume control, and only needs 2 power sockets, so there are some practical advantages to it. 

Just for the record, my listening sessions were all with 272/250DR and NDX/202/NAPSC/200DR. 

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by Dan.S
ChrisSU posted:

Also, the 272 has a better volume control, and only needs 2 power sockets, so there are some practical advantages to it.

2 power sockets? Not even with an added XPS, you do not need 2 power sockets for the 272.

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by MDS
Dan.S posted:
ChrisSU posted:

Also, the 272 has a better volume control, and only needs 2 power sockets, so there are some practical advantages to it.

2 power sockets? Not even with an added XPS, you do not need 2 power sockets for the 272.

Well it does if you want to hear it because it needs a power-amp. 

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by ChrisSU
Dan.S posted:
ChrisSU posted:

Also, the 272 has a better volume control, and only needs 2 power sockets, so there are some practical advantages to it.

2 power sockets? Not even with an added XPS, you do not need 2 power sockets for the 272.

Quite right - I meant for the system we were discussing, so one for the power amp too.

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by ChrisSU

To be fair, NDX/202/200 also only needs 2 sockets, but the chances are you'll add a NAPSC, which then makes 3.

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by Popeye

do many people use the NDX into supernait 2

 

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by ChrisSU
Popeye posted:

do many people use the NDX into supernait 2

Yes, this is a classic Naim 2-box system, and if you are searching the used market, I would certainly put it on your shortlist. Personally, I prefer the presentation of the 202/200, but I could happily live with a Supernait. 

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by ChrisH
Popeye posted:

do many people use the NDX into supernait 2

 

Yes, works well for me!

have to say though that I moved to this before the 272 was launched so I didn’t do a back to back demo. It’s a matter of personal preference between NDX/SN2 & 272/250 from what forumites have said.

Theres also the option in both cases to move to a classic 3 box system with the addition of an XPS.

sorry you couldn’t get on with the Nova though, looks like a great one box’er.

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by Adam Zielinski
Popeye posted:

do many people use the NDX into supernait 2

 

I used to run it like that - just SN and NDX. Sounds very good, clean and right.
Now it has somewhat grown into more boxes...

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by seakayaker
Popeye posted:

do many people use the NDX into supernait 2

 

I ordered the NDX & SN2 right at the year end to take advantage of the sales price of the NDX and before the price increase of 2018 for the SN2. I also listened to the 272/250DR and would have been happy with that configuration as well. The decision for easy for me since I found listening to the music from either of the configurations worked well for me and the cost for the NDX/SN2 was significantly less at the time of purchase. Still waiting for it to arrive in the shop.......

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by Timo

Two jumps at the same time from the XS series -- many congratulations!! I bet you can't wait for the arrival of your new black boxes. Apart from the price, how would you describe the difference between SN2/NDX and 272/250?

Many thanks!

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by spurrier sucks
seakayaker posted:
Popeye posted:

do many people use the NDX into supernait 2

 

I ordered the NDX & SN2 right at the year end to take advantage of the sales price of the NDX and before the price increase of 2018 for the SN2. I also listened to the 272/250DR and would have been happy with that configuration as well. The decision for easy for me since I found listening to the music from either of the configurations worked well for me and the cost for the NDX/SN2 was significantly less at the time of purchase. Still waiting for it to arrive in the shop.......

Very cool. I had an XS 2/ND5?before I bought 272/XPSDR/250DR. That was my second XS 2. I really liked that combo but think I made a great upgrade with my current setup. Hope you'll post your thoughts once you have it setup. 

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by engjoo

I am inclined to suggest a 272/250DR. Reason being the 250DR can bring you far if you plan on future upgrades into pre/power.

Posted on: 11 January 2018 by bnc1863

sorry to hear of your experiences with the Nova. I auditioned for the Nova (which I liked) but went with the 272/250DR combo instead. I bought solely based on reading this forum without any audition. Am still waiting for the 272. 

Posted on: 12 January 2018 by Massimo Bertola
Popeye posted:
Hungryhalibut posted:

There are literally thousands of posts on this, and no clear conclusion. It’s well worth searching the Forum. For what it’s worth, having owned a 202/200 in the past, I found it distinctly underwhelming without a napsc and Hicap, but very good with them. It’s ultimately a more flexible route, if that’s what you want. The NDX/Supernait 2 is another option well worth considering. 

yes sorry, i will do a search. thanks for your advise tho.

With all due respect for HH's legitimate suggestion, I personally think that what with cellphones, tablets, the apps for the units in question, TVs, smart TVs, PC or Macs, we already spend an enormous amount of time looking at a screen, just like I am doing now. Spending hours on the so called 'search facility' is another way to wear our eyes out on another screen.

Using the search facility can be useful and I myself have done it in the past, but this is also a public forum, as is sometimes proudly reminded, not so different from a sort of club of similar and heterogeneous souls, and asking to have an immediate opinion is nothing reproachable.

If I were a member of a specialized club (astronomers, poets, feet fetishists, toy train enthusiasts) and each time I ask a fellow member for an info or opinion he replied 'go and search the library', I think I'd leave in two weeks.

Why do you apologize? What exactly have you done wrong in asking?

Best

Max

Posted on: 12 January 2018 by Obsydian

Hmmm sorry to hear, i am on to my 2nd Nova.

All i would is i choose the Nova, but longer term (as a stop gap) to the prediction (possibly flawed) Naim will upgrade the Classic series with the Uniti learning.

Posted on: 12 January 2018 by Massimo Bertola
Obsydian posted:

All i would is i choose the Nova, but longer term (as a stop gap) to the prediction (possibly flawed) Naim will upgrade the Classic series with the Uniti learning.

Does this mean that the Classic series too will start to be delivered months late and one out of two samples will have flaws?

Posted on: 12 January 2018 by Obsydian

MAX-B - no idea but threw it in as a thought, like i said flawed (possibly), its akin to a i have the iPhone 8, shall i wait until the iPhone (even shinier and more expensive) is released 

But sods law, you take the plunge and ....

Posted on: 12 January 2018 by Popeye

Thanks for all your replies. Due to my issues my dealer done me a fantastic deal on a supernait 2 and a NDX. 

Hopefully this will be a less problematic affair and be superior to the Nova.

 

Thanks again

 

Popeye

Posted on: 12 January 2018 by Timo

Many congratulations -- and ENJOY!!   I haven't heard the NDX, but the SN2 -- a really nice piece of gear.