Speakers that maximize Naim sound.

Posted by: CXF04 on 28 January 2018

My system: NAP300DR, NAC552DR, CDS3/PS555DR, speakers Spendor SP100R2.

In considering new speakers I’m reminded of what Martin Colloms said when he reviewed the new DR circuit, “Naim prioritized musical communication over sound quality purity.” Reading this I realized it was probably the reason I was captivated first time I heard Naim, though unfairly it was active SBL “6-pack.” Naim’s focus unlike almost all is to allow listener to remain focused on the music without making believe they were in performance space. 

With above in mind I will shortly set off on quest for speakers to complement Naim’s embrace of “musical prioritiy.” My listening space allows speakers to be placed up to 5-feet  from wall behind them and 10-12 feet from listener, distance to side walls is more than 15-feet per speaker with speakers 10-feet apart.  Because home is apartment I do not want speakers with sound or vibration that will intrude on privacy & comfort of others. My current speakers, since addition of 552’s are dramatically improved, but I feel they lack a good measure of beauty & intimacy. After reading Forum, HiFi Critic & elsewhere, I’ve come up with three possibllities Wilson Audio Yvette, Harbeth Super HL Plus & Magico S1 Mkll. If Naim would promise to introduce speaker with voice of past I would gladly wait. I live stateside where true Naim dealers are few and market for used Naim speakers non-discernible. 

Posted on: 30 January 2018 by dave marshall

Hi, CFX04,

Just to rejoin the discussion, I started with Neat Motive 2's on the end of my first entry level Naim setup, then progressed through

MF 5's, MF 7's, to my present MF 9's.

You can check my present setup in my profile, but, at each upgrade stage I found that the Neat offering was a perfect match for my system.

I've spent some time in the company of Bob Surgeoner, joint owner of Neat, (and one of the good guys), and they do in fact use Naim kit in arriving at the voicing of their entire range of speakers. Drop him an email with any queries you might have, and he'll be only too happy to answer them.

I note from their website that there is only one US dealer listed, High Fidelity Services, in Massachusetts, and I've no idea how far away from you this might be.

If the above suggests that I'm a huge fan of Neat products, that is quite correct, as their speakers simply make great music.

Hope this helps,

Dave.

Posted on: 30 January 2018 by aht

According to the store's website, Whetstone Audio in Austin, Texas carries Neat.  However, they seem to have dropped Naim, with the exception of Mu-so.  The fellow who runs the place has been known to send out speakers for audition. High Fidelity Services appears to be the US distributor, not a retail store.

Posted on: 30 January 2018 by CXF04
themrock posted:

I have a Nap 300 DR too, my loudspeakers are Dali Epicon 6, great fit.

Themrock, thank you for your suggestion. In past Dali speakers were carried by many fine dealers, I heard them perhaps 10-years ago at a show and they did not have any appeal for me, but your mention of DALI Epicon 6 prompted me to look for review  considering your experience with 300DR.  I just read Absolute Sound review that I'd like to quote if Forum allows: "The DALI Epicon 6 is an extraordinary speaker. In high- frequency performance, in perceived resolution, and in absence of cabinet effects it is in the top echelon." And its not very big and price fits nicely within my budget. Thank you again for raising the recommendation window! One question, may I assume you feel NAP 300DR has enough power for reasonable listening? I do not play my speakers very loud, actually low based on complaints of my last equipment salesman, my musical interest is classical, heavily baroque, piano recital with some opera. Themrock thank you again!          

Posted on: 30 January 2018 by CXF04
aht posted:

According to the store's website, Whetstone Audio in Austin, Texas carries Neat.  However, they seem to have dropped Naim, with the exception of Mu-so.  The fellow who runs the place has been known to send out speakers for audition. High Fidelity Services appears to be the US distributor, not a retail store.

AHT, thank you for responding. Its actually easier and almost closer for fly to London, Austin is more than far, I am curious about neat and I know many Naim owners and British audio press favor them, or are very much at home with them. Not clear about real USA access for auditioning. Thank you again.     

Posted on: 30 January 2018 by CXF04
Skip posted:

I have the Proac D40Rs and have been happy with them since I tamed the bottom firing bass with Herbie's Fat Gliders.  

I am open to better speakers but I am not sure what.   Auditioning speakers without buying them is very difficult; you can forget hearing them "in my listening room".    Accordingly, it is a crap shoot at best.

I might be open to the next Proac up the line.   I heard the Rockports and wanted to like them based on friends who love theirs, but the rear port rules them out for me.  I heard the Magicos and liked what they did in the store; they have a fast and detailed sound and might work well with Naim or might be too much of a good thing.   The Wilsons have been an aspirational speaker for me since the Watt/Puppies but It has been a while.  Never seen a Focal.   If there were a Kudos 707 in my future, I would be open to it but there are not a dozen pairs in North America.

 

 

Skip, your current equipment certainly allows wide variety of premium speakers. Years ago I  auditioned several Proacs based on "dealer" preference, but found them too bright/intense. As I mentioned before I found the Wilson Alexia Series 2 just right, but price was twice what I budgeted, but the intimacy and focus for me were worth it. I heard them at different volumes, but was mesmerized by being able to have them above whisper with all the musical presentation, again for me it was wonderful, at least that time. Naimite shared that another Naimite with significant budget had bought unidentified Magico and after the wonder receded got rid of them in less than year. Like you I have not heard Focal, will try and hear them. I'm not audiophile and seek equipment that will allow me to listen to music without interruption or fatigue indefinitely and not many speakers are able to do that; great sound is one thing, being able to listen for 10 or 12 hours at time is often different kind of speaker. Skip, thank you for well considered thoughts!          

Posted on: 30 January 2018 by CXF04
dave marshall posted:

Hi, CFX04,

Just to rejoin the discussion, I started with Neat Motive 2's on the end of my first entry level Naim setup, then progressed through

MF 5's, MF 7's, to my present MF 9's.

You can check my present setup in my profile, but, at each upgrade stage I found that the Neat offering was a perfect match for my system.

I've spent some time in the company of Bob Surgeoner, joint owner of Neat, (and one of the good guys), and they do in fact use Naim kit in arriving at the voicing of their entire range of speakers. Drop him an email with any queries you might have, and he'll be only too happy to answer them.

I note from their website that there is only one US dealer listed, High Fidelity Services, in Massachusetts, and I've no idea how far away from you this might be.

If the above suggests that I'm a huge fan of Neat products, that is quite correct, as their speakers simply make great music.

Hope this helps,

Dave.

Dave, I'm sending question to Bob Surgeoner  and will get back to you. Thank you for your suggestion.

Posted on: 30 January 2018 by Pev
CXF04 posted:
Its actually easier and almost closer for fly to London, Austin is more than far, I am curious about neat and I know many Naim owners and British audio press favor them, or are very much at home with them. Not clear about real USA access for auditioning. Thank you again.     

Now there's a thought - with the kind of money  you are thinking of spending,  a listening holiday to London would make sense!

If you do end up with European made speakers you may even save money, especially if US hifi importers' mark ups are anywhere near as greedy  as UK ones are. 

Posted on: 30 January 2018 by CXF04

Pev, I was holding off buying additional Naim gear, as well as speakers figuring with Brexit Pound would fall into Channel, but now it looks like that's not happening. Its really not fair to American's who've been waiting to shop at Harrods at M&S prices. If you hear of crash anytime soon please post it on Forum so I can catch the next shopping flight.    

Posted on: 30 January 2018 by Pev

As far as I am concerned it's already happened. Pre brexit £ was $1,60 and 1.40 Euro now it's around 1,40 and 1.10 - bloody brexit is costing me well over £1000 a year in currency devaluation just in holiday costs 

$2 and 1.50 Euro to £1 would suit me 

Posted on: 30 January 2018 by Stephen Tate

I concur with others here on the subject of Neat speakers. I have purchased my first ever pair, the SX2s.  I have been running them with entry level Naim gears for 9 months, even now they keep on getting better and better with each listening session and they were already amazing to begin with!

Highly recommended!

Posted on: 30 January 2018 by benjy

CXF04-

I'm under the impression that you are in the New York area. There is a primarily naim dealer in Mt. Kisco that still does speaker demoes with only one set of speakers in the room and (i think) will allow for home demoes. He has (at different times) carried dynaudio,focal,dali,sonus faber. 

Posted on: 31 January 2018 by hastings

It seems strange the Spendor is performing poorly.  I would initially rule out some other problems before replacing them outright.  With so many boxes in a typical Naim system it can be hard to isolate a problem;  some I've had with my system include a faulty Naim Hiline and a power supply in need of a recap.  It took a few months of disappointing sound quality to finally recognize there was a real problem to be fixed.

SInce your initial post is a bit contradictory, I'm going to go with the assumption that you want a tonally sweeter presentation than what the Spendors are giving you.  If that is the case I would say the Harbeth's are definitely worth pursuing, as are offerings from Sonus Faber.  That would also eliminate (otherwise competent) offerings from Kudos, Neat and ATC.    

Posted on: 31 January 2018 by hastings

I'll post another strange observation I had using Spendor speakers.  I had owned them for years and felt they hadn't lived up to their glowing reviews.  I was using a naim cd player at the time.  When I bought a hugo I could turn up the volume louder than before - it was so much smoother than the naim source).  The sound from the speakers started to improve overall and it was apparent that the tweeter had never broken in properly using the Naim cd player, despite years of use.  You could argue this was simply a matter of not enough power, but I wonder if the high frequency cut off of naim cd players is a factor. 

Posted on: 02 February 2018 by Vladimir.S

INTELLIGENT SOUND PRO 8 MKII

Made in Sweden

 

Posted on: 03 February 2018 by Massimo Bertola
CXF04 posted:
Max_B posted:

And yet, a good 2nd hand pair of SBLs has the best value for money ratio on the planet. And, in spite of a silly rumour, their setup can actually be some fun, and teach something (on speakers and on Naim).

Max, I wish I had trusted dealer who inventoried and restored SBLs & DBLs, but USA for moment is not UK where many still cherish audio and keep in mind how nice it is to set time aside to listen for pleasure.   

Well, have my wishes for a lucky strike.

Max

Posted on: 03 February 2018 by Bob the Builder

Isobariks although this would need at least a Nap 250.

Posted on: 03 February 2018 by yeti42

Maybe you can grab Zoot’s NBLs when he replaces them but you might need a Snaxo and a couple more 300s.

Posted on: 03 February 2018 by northpole
yeti42 posted:

Maybe you can grab Zoot’s NBLs when he replaces them but you might need a Snaxo and a couple more 300s.

With passive cross overs, if they can be sourced,  nbl's sound great fed by a 300, more complete with a 500.

Peter

Posted on: 21 February 2018 by milpai

I have heard the ProAc D30R and D48R with some Naim gear. I liked the sound so much that I ended up buying the ProAc D48R.  Very musical I would say.

Thanks to members on this forum who helped me make a decision between the ProAc D48R and Spendor D9.

Posted on: 22 February 2018 by overprint

When auditioning new speakers to replace my old Royd Abbots/Naim pre/power, I demo'd the ProAc D30s (inoffensive but lacking that "wow" factor), SF Cremonas (lovely smooth sound but bass too much for my listening room at the time, ironically they'd work well in my new house) and Naim's SL2s (clear winners and eventual purchase). The SL2s haven't gone anywhere since and no intention of selling. Each upgrade elsewhere and they've got better and better. I run them passive rather than active (52/135s)

Posted on: 23 February 2018 by patk

Hi CFX04,

Regarding Neat speakers.  If you contact the importer,  High Fidelity Services, they may be able to arrange a home demo with you.  Or work with a local dealer you are familiar with.  They offered both options to me last year, but  I decided to put it on hold since I am considering a move.  

Best regards,

pat

Posted on: 23 February 2018 by Minh Nguyen

If possible try out Wilson Benesch speakers. I've listened to many speakers but the portrayal of music is unsurpassed in my humble opinion.

Posted on: 24 February 2018 by Massimo Bertola

And, going back to the thread's original caption, if I am allowed a lousy pun (that won't have a meaning for most), I add N-Sats.

M.