roon - what am I missing?

Posted by: Frank Yang on 07 August 2018

I have 4000+ albums in a QNAP NAS plus subscriptions to QoBuz and Tidal, and I am running Audirvana plus with UPnP on a dedicated MM. So I can play Tidal masters and Qobuz sublime+ with Audirvana plus streaming from my MM regardless whether my source is from files stored in my NAS or Tidal masters or Qobuz 192/24.

So my question is, what am I missing? What does ROON give me what MM + Audirvana plus UPnP does not? Should I pay $500 for all the things that I do not need?

Posted on: 20 August 2018 by Thorsten_L

Interesting topic.

Do I understand the following correctly:

1) Roon must be installed on my PC.

2) I tell Roon then where my local music on my PC is stored.

3) Roon can access my music stored internally in my Core.

4) I can control my music on the PC and on the Core with Roon either via Desktop or iPad Roon app?

5) To do this, my PC with Roon must be switched on and online.

Thank you.

 

Posted on: 20 August 2018 by ChrisSU
Thorsten_L posted:

1) Roon must be installed on my PC.

2) I tell Roon then where my local music on my PC is stored.

3) Roon can access my music stored internally in my Core.

4) I can control my music on the PC and on the Core with Roon either via Desktop or iPad Roon app?

5) To do this, my PC with Roon must be switched on and online. 

1) Yes, or you can run it on a NAS. 

2) Yes, Roon will search your network for music folders, not just the computer it runs on. 

3) Yes

4) Yes

5) Yes

Posted on: 20 August 2018 by Thorsten_L

Cool. Many thanks.

Roon will search for music stored on my PC, but can I also manually tell it which folder it needs to have? 

Like if I don't want to use a folder for example with temporary music on it...

Posted on: 20 August 2018 by Frank Yang
Thorsten_L posted:

Cool. Many thanks.

Roon will search for music stored on my PC, but can I also manually tell it which folder it needs to have? 

Like if I don't want to use a folder for example with temporary music on it...

You have to tell roon where to find your music regardless whether it is on your PC or on a network drive, or in a folder on an internal/external drive, and you can tell it to ignore any folder.

Basically, there is no black magic.

Posted on: 20 August 2018 by Thorsten_L

Sounds great. Thanks.

Posted on: 20 August 2018 by ChrisSU
Thorsten_L posted:

Cool. Many thanks.

Roon will search for music stored on my PC, but can I also manually tell it which folder it needs to have? 

Like if I don't want to use a folder for example with temporary music on it...

As Frank says, you have to tell Roon which of your music folders you want it to access. This may involve a small amount if head scratching, but you only have to do it once. 

Posted on: 20 August 2018 by Jan-Erik Nordoen

[@mention:1566878604003891].

Hi Thorsten,

If you want to run Roon with your current system (as in your profile), you'll need to add a Roon-ready bridge in front of your nDAC. An alternative is to use the USB output of the computer on which Roon Core is installed, and a USB to S/PDIF converter (e.g., HiFace 2) to connect to the nDAC. If you stay with the latter route, addition of a USB isolator / regenerator (e.g., Intona USB high-speed isolator) into the signal path is worth doing.

Hope this helps,

Jan

Posted on: 20 August 2018 by Alley Cat
Thorsten_L posted:

Interesting topic.

Do I understand the following correctly:

3) Roon can access my music stored internally in my Core.

4) I can control my music on the PC and on the Core with Roon either via Desktop or iPad Roon app?

5) To do this, my PC with Roon must be switched on and online.

Thank you.

 

While Roon may be able to access the media on the Core I don't think it could use the Core as an output device - as far as I'm aware the Core is not a Roon endpoint and does not have the RAAT 'engine' that the other Unitis have - just in case you were considering trying Roon to output via the Core's SPDIF output.

 

Posted on: 20 August 2018 by Thorsten_L
Jan-Erik Nordoen posted:

[@mention:1566878604003891].

Hi Thorsten,

If you want to run Roon with your current system (as in your profile), you'll need to add a Roon-ready bridge in front of your nDAC. An alternative is to use the USB output of the computer on which Roon Core is installed, and a USB to S/PDIF converter (e.g., HiFace 2) to connect to the nDAC. If you stay with the latter route, addition of a USB isolator / regenerator (e.g., Intona USB high-speed isolator) into the signal path is worth doing.

Hope this helps,

Jan

Oh. Thank you... I apologise. I updated my profile.

Posted on: 20 August 2018 by Thorsten_L
Alley Cat posted:
Thorsten_L posted:

Interesting topic.

Do I understand the following correctly:

3) Roon can access my music stored internally in my Core.

4) I can control my music on the PC and on the Core with Roon either via Desktop or iPad Roon app?

5) To do this, my PC with Roon must be switched on and online.

Thank you.

 

While Roon may be able to access the media on the Core I don't think it could use the Core as an output device - as far as I'm aware the Core is not a Roon endpoint and does not have the RAAT 'engine' that the other Unitis have - just in case you were considering trying Roon to output via the Core's SPDIF output.

 

Thanks. That means I can't choose my Core in the Roon software so that the Core sends it through the nDAC to my ears?

Deal breaker then. Ok.

Posted on: 20 August 2018 by Alley Cat
Thorsten_L posted:
Alley Cat posted:
Thorsten_L posted:

Interesting topic.

Do I understand the following correctly:

3) Roon can access my music stored internally in my Core.

4) I can control my music on the PC and on the Core with Roon either via Desktop or iPad Roon app?

5) To do this, my PC with Roon must be switched on and online.

Thank you.

 

While Roon may be able to access the media on the Core I don't think it could use the Core as an output device - as far as I'm aware the Core is not a Roon endpoint and does not have the RAAT 'engine' that the other Unitis have - just in case you were considering trying Roon to output via the Core's SPDIF output.

 

Thanks. That means I can't choose my Core in the Roon software so that the Core sends it through the nDAC to my ears?

Deal breaker then. Ok.

I don't believe so, but I hope I'm wrong.

Posted on: 20 August 2018 by Terrysmi

You are correct 

Posted on: 20 August 2018 by Frank Yang

Roon does output on the Core, that is why I am able to send music via SPDIF.

Posted on: 20 August 2018 by Terrysmi

frank , what was connected to the Core? as far as i understand it the Core is not a Roon output device 

Posted on: 20 August 2018 by Thorsten_L
Frank Yang posted:

Roon does output on the Core, that is why I am able to send music via SPDIF.

So, practically speaking, I sit on my PC. I tell Roon which music I want to be included (Core and PC). I choose the Core as output device in Roon and the Core plays then the music through my nDAC?

 

Posted on: 20 August 2018 by Frank Yang
Terrysmi posted:

frank , what was connected to the Core? as far as i understand it the Core is not a Roon output device ked

The Core is my Mac Mini - So when I start Roon on my MM, go to Settings -> Audio, it immediately recognizes the system output, the built-in output, various USB outputs, Airplay and various streamers (aka networked devices) that I have in the house, it even sees a couple of my old Airport Express'es lying around the house as Airplay output devices. You can then pick any output you like on the Core when you are playing your music.

You can control the Roon Core using your latop, iPad, iPhone, etc. In my case, my MM is headless, so I run a Roon control app on my Windows 10 Surface Pro.

Posted on: 20 August 2018 by Alley Cat

Frank, I think there may be some confusion - your 'Core' is the 'Roon Core' i.e. the device running the Roon software - Thorsten wants to use a 'Roon core' on PC to control audio output on his Uniti Core - this is what I think may not be possible - I don't have a Uniti Core so may be wrong but I don't think the Uniti Core has the RAAT software needed by Roon to control output from the Roon Core.

Posted on: 21 August 2018 by ChrisSU

Yes, there seems to be some confusion here between the ‘Roon Core’ and the ‘Naim Core’. Roon Core is the main Roon software that runs on your computer, and as the Naim one is not a Roon Endpoint, it would need a network connection. 

The Roon Core computer can then play via SPDIF into a DAC. 

Posted on: 22 August 2018 by Frank Yang

Yep, I got mixed-up, I thought Thorsten meant the Roon Core

Btw, the Roon DSP sounds awful, flat, mushy, muddy, disabling it bring back the familiar crisp, clean, fresh sound that I am used to. Maybe I do not know how to set it up properly.

Posted on: 22 August 2018 by SimonPeterArnold
Frank Yang posted:

Yep, I got mixed-up, I thought Thorsten meant the Roon Core

Btw, the Roon DSP sounds awful, flat, mushy, muddy, disabling it bring back the familiar crisp, clean, fresh sound that I am used to. Maybe I do not know how to set it up properly.

Depends on  what your doing with DSP and what your wanting to achieve. 

Posted on: 22 August 2018 by Innocent Bystander

DSP cannot correct all room prop lems - e.g. with nulls all you will domin trying to boost te signal is risk blowing the speakers. It is best used after physically correcting as much as can be, and then in moderation.

Posted on: 22 August 2018 by Halloween Man

Roon, or any other software, offers no better sound quality than iTunes when playing ripped CDs as Apple Lossless, bit perfect. I don't understand why few use iTunes and Apple Lossless. Apple's remote app on iphone or ipad also offers remote control of iTunes. Multi room is handled by Airplay. When you update OS X or IOS everything continues to work, unlike Audirvana or Roon which have to continuously play catch up with OS X or IOS updates.

Posted on: 22 August 2018 by David O'Higgins
Halloween Man posted:

Roon, or any other software, offers no better sound quality than iTunes when playing ripped CDs as Apple Lossless, bit perfect. I don't understand why few use iTunes and Apple Lossless. Apple's remote app on iphone or ipad also offers remote control of iTunes. Multi room is handled by Airplay. When you update OS X or IOS everything continues to work, unlike Audirvana or Roon which have to continuously play catch up with OS X or IOS updates.

Gimme a break! Roon has nothing to do with sound quality, and everything to do with managing your library. It also updates itself seamlessly. Please try it?

Posted on: 22 August 2018 by Halloween Man

Seriously, I have tried it and liked it, it was my second favourite after iTunes. iTunes manages my library of CDs just fine, no problems whatsoever. Roon did not offer any better sound quality.

Posted on: 22 August 2018 by David O'Higgins
Halloween Man posted:

Seriously, I have tried it and liked it, it was my second favourite after iTunes. iTunes manages my library of CDs just fine, no problems whatsoever. Roon did not offer any better sound quality.

Wow! Must give iTunes another try. I must be missing something.......