Play across or along a long sitting room?

Posted by: JimDog on 14 November 2018

My sitting/listening room is 11x22ft. The HiFi is currently set up across the width of the room. Should I set it up at one end and play the sound along the room - then I can move the sofa further away or closer to change the listening distance? And is it always best to aim for an equilateral triangle between the 2 speakers and the person, or does it just depend on the room and personal preference? Has anyone ever achieved great SQ far from equilaleral proportions?

Posted on: 16 November 2018 by RaceTripper
JimDog posted:

Brian von Bork from Cardas Audio just told me:

"There is no rule for toe in as it is speaker and room dependent. Trial and error is required. In a perfect world the distance between the speakers should be the same as the distance to the listening chair. This creates an equilateral triangle."

...

That always seemed obvious to me. I always start with speakers firing straight on to start with, and work from there until I have the desired affect for system, speakers and room.

Posted on: 16 November 2018 by Guinnless
RaceTripper posted:
JimDog posted:

Brian von Bork from Cardas Audio just told me:

"There is no rule for toe in as it is speaker and room dependent. Trial and error is required. In a perfect world the distance between the speakers should be the same as the distance to the listening chair. This creates an equilateral triangle."

...

That always seemed obvious to me. I always start with speakers firing straight on to start with, and work from there until I have the desired affect for system, speakers and room.

I do the same and give myself a few days, then adjust further if required.

Posted on: 16 November 2018 by RaceTripper
Guinnless posted:
RaceTripper posted:
JimDog posted:

Brian von Bork from Cardas Audio just told me:

"There is no rule for toe in as it is speaker and room dependent. Trial and error is required. In a perfect world the distance between the speakers should be the same as the distance to the listening chair. This creates an equilateral triangle."

...

That always seemed obvious to me. I always start with speakers firing straight on to start with, and work from there until I have the desired affect for system, speakers and room.

I do the same and give myself a few days, then adjust further if required.

For new speakers it take me much longer than that. It changes as the speakers break in. I'm into my new speakers for just over a month now and still making tweaks as they change from running in. Dynaudio's Esotar2 tweeter is notorious for long break in times.

Posted on: 16 November 2018 by Guinnless

My Spendor A7s are just two months old.  Once fully run in I tweaked the toe in over a week. 

My motorbike laser chain alignment tool came in handy for getting the positions correct.  ☺

Posted on: 16 November 2018 by RaceTripper
Guinnless posted:

My Spendor A7s are just two months old.  Once fully run in I tweaked the toe in over a week. 

My motorbike laser chain alignment tool came in handy for getting the positions correct.  ☺

I have a laser sharp tool for aligning my speakers too. My ears. 

Posted on: 16 November 2018 by JimDog

Yes, experimenting with speaker position is an art form in itself.

What I've realized from this thread is:

i) speakers should disappear/merge when they are just right

ii) speakers can be closer together than seems 'normal' (e.g. Nigel's 1.9m)

iii) the proportions between the 3 sides of the speakers/head horizontal triangle are closer to equilateral than I thought (but in the end totally individual)

iv) there is also a vertical triangle to hone (as per Racetipper's subwoofer on the floor and tweeters up above his head)

iv) there is not even consensus on whether it's best to aim along or across the room

v) sidewalls and ceilings matter more than I realized

and most of all -

vi) despite what it says in the manual, it sounds fantastic when you aim them right at your head