Advanced search

This *****

Posted by: Kevin Hughes on 31 July 2000

I am not impressed with the new software (polite opinion ). This software is totaly round earth, looks nice but fails to do the basic job properly.

Can we have an uncensored part please?

What happens if you chose the "under 16" option?

Tony & Mike, who did you sleep with to ge to full member (oh err etc..) status.

Kevin.

PS still no spell checker either, just pants.

Posted on: 31 July 2000 by Mike Hanson
Yes, this software is useful only for forums that have no more than a couple of messages in each thread. It just feels like a room full of people shouting at each other. There's not enough organization to the conversations. It is pretty, though.

As far as getting full member status, it's probably based on the number of messages posted. Catch you later!

-=> Mike Hanson <=-


[This message was edited by Mike Hanson on MONDAY 31 July 2000 at 20:38.]

Posted on: 31 July 2000 by Kevin Hughes
quote:
As far as getting full member status, it's probably based on the number of messages posted. Catch you later!

So it encorages spam as well, great.

Kevin.

Posted on: 31 July 2000 by Tony L
As far as getting full member status, it's probably based on the number of messages posted. Catch you later!

How much spam needed to get to administrator?

Tony.

Posted on: 31 July 2000 by Former member
...it's peeling the polish off Petrik's toenails!

When I got pissed off on the original forum, a large part of it was to do with Naim's failure to understand the importance of their cybercreation. Look what's happened now. How could anyone with any experience with the old forum reach the conclusion that this pathetic software would handle the job??? I think it's time to admit a big mistake has been made and start looking for another host.
















Vuk.

Posted on: 31 July 2000 by Mike Hanson
My web hosting service said they could handle the old ColdFusion/MSSQL setup, but Naim told me that they weren't really interested. Maybe they'll reconsider that with all of the negative feedback that they're getting.

Smilies do not a forum make.

-=> Mike Hanson <=-

Posted on: 31 July 2000 by Kevin Hughes
I hope someone from Naim comments on this soon, I will understand if they think we will get use to it and want to wait a few days, but onyl a few days.

In the meantime I urge everyone to vote in the Padded Cell - New Forum thread. If enough of us vote negativly I hope Naim have the balls to admit there mistake. It will be intrested to see if the negative view of the new software is held by most or just software developers used to ripping other people's systems to bits (like me).

Kevin.

Posted on: 31 July 2000 by Former member
Yup you got my vote.

This thing doth truly SUCK!!!!

Posted on: 31 July 2000 by Former member
Actually - Having spent an hour or so with this thing it really isn't all that bad.

Amazing how many hits this thing gets in relation to the ammount of actual postings -creepy.

Nice to see they've posted a piccy of the best CD player they've ever made as well.

regardez

Soon to be an ex junior member ?

Posted on: 31 July 2000 by Bob Edwards
Hey gang--

I am a bit undecided as to how this flows or if I like it or not. . .

We should, however, avoid falling into the trap of assuming the old one was better because we knew it longer.

Cheers,

Bob

Posted on: 31 July 2000 by Former member
Bob.

I appreciate what you're saying, but many of us are quite familiar with this software, having had experience with it on the Exposure, Dynavector and Royd conferences (they can actually get away with it to some extent because of the very low volume, but one good day of naim traffic can equal 2 months of exposure chat). Moreover, as someone who designs interfaces, I can assure you that this is one of the most simplistic and inadequate fronts for the task at hand that I have ever seen. One would assume by looking at it that computers weren't really capable of very much. Almost like the designers were thinking of DOS when the put it together. There are a lot of IT pros among us and I'm sure they'll all back me on this.

















































Vuk. .

Posted on: 31 July 2000 by Mike Hanson
quote:
We should, however, avoid falling into the trap of assuming the old one was better because we knew it longer.

There are various sites which use this same software (including the Royd and Exposure conferences), and I've been hating them for quite a while now too. Fortunately, there aren't as many messages on them as there is on the Naim forum. With our usual volume, pure chaos will ensue. In fact it's already begun, since I have a terrible time determining if there are any new messages and how they fit into the flow of the various converstations.

With the old forum software, I had a single screen with three purposeful panels. One showed a list of all recent threads in all conferences; the second showed the message tree for the currently selected thread, and the third showed the text of the currently selected message. It was a perfect Forest-and-Trees approach, and very similar to many newgroup readers (like Agent).

With this software I'm lost! I'm constantly maneuvering from page to page in hopes of determing whether anything new is being posted anywhere. I'm forever re-reading messages to determine if I've read them already. It's not enough to jump to the bottom of the page, as then you must scan backwards to see where the new messages start. If you're really unlucky, the thread will be long enough to flow onto multiple pages. To top it off, each time you post a new message, you're thrown back to page one, and you must manually click back to the last page, just to see if your post appeared correctly!!!

It's absolute and utter crap!!!!

-=> Mike Hanson <=-
Smilies do not a forum make

Posted on: 31 July 2000 by Mike Hanson
Hallelujah, brother! I love the graffiti, even though it's made from those superfluous smilies. Catch you later!

-=> Mike Hanson <=-
Smilies do not a forum make.

Posted on: 31 July 2000 by Former member
Boy, you guys can really whine.
Posted on: 31 July 2000 by Mike Hanson
quote:
Boy, you guys can really whine.

Sure, but only for a good cause. Catch you later!

-=> Mike Hanson <=-
Smilies do not a forum make.

Posted on: 31 July 2000 by dave simpson
Anyone got a map for this puppy?

testing earth to dave,

dave

vuk, how bout a map with that cd

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Former member
There seem to be a few comments about following threads and volume of posts.

If the new software keeps the number of posts down we might all be better off, after all it should be:-

quality not quantity

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Former member
Does anyone know how you can thread replies on this forum, or do you just reply to the whole thread.

Looks to me like this software doesn't support a good (or bad) argument.

Cliff<BR>
NAP500 Prisoner

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Mick P
Gentlemen

This system needs tweaking but there are some good points.

Its quicker than the old one

There is a lot more information avaiable

The faces obviously appeal to Vuk.

Long threads do not narrow down, just look at the thread on Mana Stealth where two of our fraternity have caused the screen to reduce to 1 inch in width.

The major problem is the lack of developing a thread within a thread. If some computer genius can sort that problem out, then in all fairness we have a much better system.

I think the faces are childish, but then I am just grumpy.

Regards

Mick

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Mick P
Gentlemen

This system needs tweaking but there are some good points.

Its quicker than the old one

There is a lot more information avaiable

The faces obviously appeal to Vuk.

You can jump in and out when writing letters which is useful

Long threads do not narrow down, just look at the thread on Mana Stealth where two of our fraternity have caused the screen to reduce to 1 inch in width because of the multitude of letters.

The major problem is the lack of developing a thread within a thread. If some computer genius can sort that problem out, then in all fairness we have a much better system.

I think the faces are childish, but then I am just grumpy.

Regards

Mick

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Former member
Let's give it a day or two. It looks pretty, with nice little features, like images, fonts etc., but it's hard to use in the basic level, just viewing messages and following threads etc. I liked the "round earth" analogy, can you hear the pinpoint imaging around here ???

But one major thing is so much better : Vuk's here.

Omer

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Mick P
Chaps

This is my second attempt to reply so I am obviously being slow in picking this up.

Basically, I like this new system providing it gets tweaked at some later date.

It seems a lo faster than the old one.

You have a lot more information to look at.

The personal profiles are "nice". BTW Mike Hanson is the spitting image of me when I was a few years yopunger. So I am what he will be like in twenty years from now.

The bandwidth does not narrow on very long threads such as the rather dull and boring one on Mana Stealth.

Vuk, in particular, loves the faces. It has brought out his creative personna.

The major problem is not being able to respond to specif letters. If that issue is cracked then it gets my vote.

I am fairly happy

Regards

Mick

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Rico
Mike

I am pleased to report that this new forum has generated one*** (and one only) positive thing: I am in complete agreement with you on your post! <insert yer smiley face wid da wraps 'ere>

Overall it sucks - the first time a new Naim product has been worse than that which it replaced.

Rico - musichead

{***edited - oh, two things - it's bought Vuk back to complain, too!}

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by BrianD
Cliff is spot on.

I started reading the forum last October and have found it very enlightening, entertaining and, for the most part, excellent reading. I don't buy hi-fi magazines, I get more pleasure from following the forum.

The whole point of the forum is being able to follow a thread. Many times I have posted comments in the middle of what had become fairly long threads. Other people do the same all the time. They then follow that particular part of the topic closely, while still 'monitoring' the rest. Mike has made this point a couple of times too. That people are unable to do this now is enough reason to consign this effort to the bin. The whole thing is just cumbersome and too difficult to follow

Something needs to be done or I can see contributions dropping if it stays like this.
That would be a real pity and a great loss to everyone.

Brian Jnr

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Jo Sharp
Let us try to be constructive to support our friends in salisbury; E-mail our suggestions for improvements to them (without spamming).

I would like to see proper thread management better to follow replies in sub-threads, with the headers listed at the beginning so you don't have to read every entry to find an item of particular interest.

And the new message system restored.

In other words, the old forum back, but on a new server!!


Jo

Posted on: 01 August 2000 by Mike Hanson
quote:
Mike Hanson is the spitting image of me when I was a few years yopunger. So I am what he will be like in twenty years from now.

So why don't you have a picture in the profile section. I want to know where I'm headed . Catch you later!

-=> Mike Hanson <=-


Smilies do not a forum make.

[This message was edited by Mike Hanson on TUESDAY 01 August 2000 at 15:31.]