Advanced search

This *****

Posted by: Kevin Hughes on 31 July 2000

I am not impressed with the new software (polite opinion ). This software is totaly round earth, looks nice but fails to do the basic job properly.

Can we have an uncensored part please?

What happens if you chose the "under 16" option?

Tony & Mike, who did you sleep with to ge to full member (oh err etc..) status.

Kevin.

PS still no spell checker either, just pants.

Posted on: 02 August 2000 by BrianD
Geoff

Thanks for your comment.

To clarify a little. I have no problems browsing. It's actually a lot faster than the old forum, the pages appearing almost instantly. I am simply curious as to why any posts I add to a thread don't seem to appear for a considerable time.
For example, something I posted yesterday hadn't appeared for so long (20 minutes) I logged off and checked it this morning.

Of course, this isn't a big issue. Just wondering.

Brian

Posted on: 02 August 2000 by Phil Barry
And again we have Bob Edwards who's an outlier! I hope Bob sees some humor in this.

Just for the record, Bob, I've found your contributions informative and useful, and if I've offended you, I apoliogize; it was certainly not my intention.

This new forum is not. I agree with all the negative statements above.

Except that I stay off the Royd, Exposure, Dynavector sites because they're so hard to follow.

Who's hosting this, anyway?

Posted on: 02 August 2000 by Martin Payne
quote:
Martin, if we had not used the infopop forum, we would not have any forum at all for some time, all estimates and promises to keep the old forum and re-site just did not materialise. We will look at the situation and see what we can do.


Paul,

I'm obviously pleased to see the forum continue, in whatever form. I quite appreciate the new look (although as a mainframe programmer I'm supposed to value only function and consider aesthetics irrelevant!)

I do think, though, that the usage of this forum will be different from the previous one. There will be benefits all round if a solution can be found.

cheers, Martin

Posted on: 04 August 2000 by Former member
And if we can't have a good argument what are we to do Cliff?

I am like many who think this new forum is inferior to the previous one which worked well and has now been removed.

Ian

Posted on: 04 August 2000 by Nic Peeling
Can I propose we wind this thread down? I suggest that Paul Stephenson puts out an official statement as to what (if anything) Naim propose to do to satisfy those who are unhappy with the Forum software, and possibly summarise the reasons for making their initial decisions about the new forum.

I suspect most forum members are most concerned about maintaining the quality of the content of the forum. The thing that worries me most is that the content so far does not yet match the old forum's.

Nic P

Posted on: 04 August 2000 by Ron Toolsie
It seems ironic to me that the the ability to use emoticons on this forum is sort of like having a tone control. And the ability to easily boldface text is sort of like having a loudness button. Does this mean that the 52.5 will incorporate these very latest developments

Ron

Posted on: 04 August 2000 by Former member
yes, this is absolute junk
Posted on: 04 August 2000 by Former member
The way this forum is now structured makes a "discussion" read like a barely connected series of comments. It is impossible to follow the structure of a discussion. It is going to prove extremely difficult to slag each other off effectively.

The only good thing is the profiles, which allows you to "jostle your member memory"


Andy

Not Smiling !

Posted on: 04 August 2000 by Paul Davies
Perhaps it's time for the rec.audio.naim usenet newsgroup.
Posted on: 04 August 2000 by Laxton
....less than a week with this new forum format and i'm really irritated just trying to read the posts!

laxton

Posted on: 05 August 2000 by Former member
Hi Paul,

Last I heard, 6% of people on the net use the usenet discussion groups to any extent.

Many people have read only news access, many people accessing from work could only view it via dejanews or similar with a day or two of lag in the messages.

This is probably why Naim have a web forum.

I love usenet and I'm an old net hand (KOTF in an alt group for years), but I don't think that's gonna work for this community of users.

:-(

Joel

Born to groove

Posted on: 05 August 2000 by Andrew Randle
This forum is in serious need of *threads*

...or maybe I've missed the feature.

Andrew

Andrew Randle
2B || !2B;
4 ^ = ?;

Posted on: 06 August 2000 by Former member
I'm extremely disappointed..... this forum is the antithesis of all the core naim values we love.
The lack of a "thread" .. the discussions don't make sense, the character has gone.... can't see myself enjoying this one like the old one...
Posted on: 06 August 2000 by Peter Goldsmith
The lack of a tree structure for this forum truly bites the big one!! Why is this supposed to be considered an advancement? Less information, more censorship, cute smiley icons.....hmmmmmm.

Peter Goldsmith
pmgoldsmith@earthlink.net

Posted on: 07 August 2000 by bob atherton
Hi to friends from the previous forum,

I have waited a little while before posting on this one. Firstly because the surroundings were _so_ unfamiliar & a bit of
acclimatization time was necessary. I feel a bit like first day at a new school! Secondly because my ISP has just changed &
that took a bit of setting up as well.

What do I personally think of this forum? With my diplomatic hat on, I think I agree with a lot of criticisms put forward by
most of the other forums contributors. I think/hope in time the tree thread thingy can be resurrected, & so make navigation
easier & more fun.

I would like to think after many years of using, & at one point selling Naim equipment I have a fairly good idea how the team at
Salisbury function. I am confident that they are also not too thrilled with this off the shelf package and will do what they can to
tweak it. I think to carry on moaning about things is not constructive, & apart from anything else Paul must look like a
patchwork quilt with all those patches!

Plus points for the new forum? Well, Vuk is back........... thats about it really.

Bo

Posted on: 07 August 2000 by Ian P
The most significant loss is definitely the lack of threads in the threads. Who am I replying to ? Even I don't know.

Ian

P.S. My 7 year old son is progressing from infant to junior school next term. I seem to have regressed to a similar state.

Posted on: 07 August 2000 by Former member
Hey Ian (Wright, and Pog, who's comments I've read elsewhere and seem to mirror yours), don't forget, please, that we didn't just switch off the old forum, it was switched off for us, we had no choice in the matter.
Posted on: 07 August 2000 by Andy S
Mark T/Paul S,

I think a clear statement of what/if anything is going to be done would help us all. There is some severe dissatisfaction with the service that we have moved to (and we all understand why this has happened...). Knowing where you are going would quieten us all down so...

1) Do Naim intend keeping the forum software as it is now?

2) If changing, what sort of timescale can we expect things to change over?

3) If changing, what user features will be on the requirements list for any new implementation? [hint: threading and expanding new messages appear to be the biggest gripes...]

I think we all appreciate that since everyone is out at Naim, it is more difficult to proceed but some form of official Naim statement, either way, would help right now.

And

Posted on: 07 August 2000 by Dev B
I'm not a netxpert like many of you but I quite like extra things you can do here, but I do miss the threaded discussion.

Lets give it time - it's better than nothing and I'm sure Naim will listen to the comments made here and haven't they been on hols or something?

Dev.

Posted on: 07 August 2000 by Paul Stephenson
Andy...
1. Do Naim intend keeping the forum software as it is now?

WE ARE GOING TO DO EVERYTHING POSSIBLE TO CHANGE THE SET UP.

2) If changing, what sort of timescale can we expect things to change over?

NO IDEA, FIRST WE WILL TRY TO IMPROVE THIS SITE, IF NOT, WE CAN DECIDE WHAT OTHER FORUMS ARE AVAILABLE AND IF NOTHING IS SUITABLE, DO WE STILL WANT A FORUM IF YOU DO NOT LIKE IT?

3) If changing, what user features will be on the requirements list for any new implementation? [hint: threading and expanding new messages appear to be the biggest gripes...]

ALL THE ONES WE ALL KNOW ABOUT.


Posted on: 07 August 2000 by Trevor Warwick
quote:
DO WE STILL WANT A FORUM IF YOU DO NOT LIKE IT?

I, for one, would still want to have the forum available, even in its current state (you should still try to improve the usability though).

Trevor

Posted on: 07 August 2000 by Former member
1. Yes I do want a forum
2. Having followed a few topics threading is a big issue.
3. I am already missing access to the information in the old forum
4. I hate the smilies
5. I am not going to stop liking naim because the forum has changed

Simon

Posted on: 07 August 2000 by Jonathan Gorse
Paul,

Welcome back from holiday - hope you managed to get away from all this at least some of the time.

Whatever you do don't kill the forum. It may be a state right now but I suspect they'd be marching on Salisbury and picketing the Hammersmith show if you even hinted at getting rid of it altogether!

I have said it before and it bears repeating this is the finest dammned bit of the internet to some of us and the best thing we can all do is provide suggestions and assistance where possible to you to ensure that the forum continues to function as Julian would have wanted. I always feel that his spirit lives on through this forum.

I understand Vuk is trying to come up with a solution and I'm sure you guys are too. Let's give people a chance.

Can I add 'smaller font' to the wish-list - each message seems to fill a page at the moment.

Jonathan

Posted on: 07 August 2000 by Andy S
quote:
WE ARE GOING TO DO EVERYTHING POSSIBLE TO CHANGE THE SET UP.

Excellent. I'll stick with it for the moment. Just knowing that someone is looking into it helps allay fears.

quote:
NO IDEA, FIRST WE WILL TRY TO IMPROVE THIS SITE, IF NOT, WE CAN DECIDE WHAT OTHER FORUMS ARE AVAILABLE AND IF NOTHING IS SUITABLE, DO WE STILL WANT A FORUM IF YOU DO NOT LIKE IT?

I think you should still keep the forum BUT I think it's usefulness will be diminished if people "don't like it".

Andy

Posted on: 07 August 2000 by bob atherton

"I have said it before and it bears repeating this is the finest dammned bit of the internet to some of us and the best thing we can all do is provide suggestions and assistance where possible to you to ensure that the forum continues to function as Julian would have wanted. I always feel that his spirit lives on through this forum."

Jonathan,

Extremely well put, I really could not agree more. I am tempted to post your eloquent paragraph on every current thread, but that is not good netiquette, so I won't.

Bob