The best standard power cord?

Posted by: Efraim roots on 25 January 2010

Greetings!
Naim is very sensitive to installation I have learned and I'm trying to get most out of my 202/200. I got the 'I Sheng' powercord with the nap200 and I today thought that I should try a 'Ching Cheng' that came with my Lingo2 on the nap200. I also did a search on this forum and read that 'ching cheng' also been used as standard cord with Naim equipment aswell as Linn.

I must say that the difference is really fundamental were the 'ching cheng' is more warm, tuneful and balanced the 'I sheng' is more cold and clear, more 'hammering' rythmwize. I think I prefer the ching cheng in the long run but I will experiment some more.

I also compared the 'I sheng' with a recent Linn standard cord called 'Tongyuan' on my Lingo2 and did not hear the same differences as on the amp, here the Tongyuan was simply better on everything, tunwize, PRAT and soundwize.

Have somebody tried and compared the different standard cords sent with Naim equipment? Wich do you prefer? Have you taken notice on the direction of the cable? It's a shame that the direction of standard cables are random. I would like to know wich is best musically and PRATwize.

If I buy a new cord from my Naim dealer which will I likley get today? Im located in northern Europe.
Posted on: 26 January 2010 by abbydog
quote:
I think the key is thinking in terms of not how bad the wire further up the chain is but how good could it be if it were improved (proven by by improving that last little bit called the power cord.)


Sounds to me like you're the one worrying too much about wire, Dave... have you noticed, during your time in IT, how much the performance of a PC soundcard improves with different power chords?
Posted on: 26 January 2010 by dave simpson
Abby,

I've never heard a PC soundcard worth using muchless trying to improve with a power cord or anything else.

Regarding my preference in power cords, I use the free ones that came with my gear.

Regarding my quote from the past, I still stand behind it.

BTW, I'm not the one getting angry over others having a power cord discussion. I wonder if you misunderstood my earlier post? I wasn't making light of anyone's frustration over power cords or AC distribution, rather worrying about what others do within this hobby. If a subset of hobbyists wish to set their rigs on fire with gasoline and a torch, have at it, so long as you don't harm anyone.


regards,

dave
Posted on: 26 January 2010 by Efraim roots
dave wrote:
quote:
Regarding my preference in power cords, I use the free ones that came with my gear


Hi dave,
This is what this discussion were ment to be about. Because Naim has different standard cables, and it would be interesting to hear if any user had find some which is superior. Maybe the recent standard called 'xxxx' is better than the standard from 5 years ago called 'yyyyy'?

In the case of LINN one of their recent standard cables is called 'Tongyuan' and is by far superior to the 'Ching Cheng' supplied with LINN 10 years ago. The difference is fundamental and upgrading cost peanuts.
Posted on: 26 January 2010 by dave simpson
I'm with you Efraim. I've found myself somewhat undecided between the Volex/Mayor and Tibias supplied by the Naim factory over the years for the US market. I'm going to revisit all the combinations in the near future after making some recent improvements to system setup which I hope will make the differences more profound. At the moment it's almost a toss-up with a slight preference to the Mayor and Volex vs the Tibia. Don't get me wrong, the differences between all were clear, just not extremely important. That may change now.

FWIW, many years ago I experimented with my Linn system's power cords after getting a tip from our distributor. I replaced the factory cords with exactly the same brand and spec wire and plugs only one wire gauge larger. Slight improvement at a very low cost.

regards,

dave
Posted on: 26 January 2010 by JeremyB
best: Tongyuan supplied with the box (writing is in direction from box to wall)
next best: thicker cable (Tibia) supplied with 500 series box (writing is in direction from wall to box)
worst by far: thicker cable (Tibia) supplied separately by Naim dealer (writing is in direction from box to wall)

YMMV.........
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by mongo
Lo Efraim. I have 5 inch silver round things which i stick in the hole of my cd5 and then press the play button and enjoy the following noise. Smile

Sorry mate! Don't mean to sound like a t**t, but i do feel you are in danger of missing the point.

Unless something is obviously wrong, might I suggest you stick all cables in to a common ground, plug in, and focus on the songs?
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by Christopher_M
Paul [mongo], Top post! Smile

Best, Chris
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by Efraim roots
mongo,
It is all about attention to detail in your installation to make your very expensive kit to make the most. I will also have my second hand NACA5 resoldered by a real pro to know there is no weak links. Installation is a very large % of your end result.
In every test I do don't give a shit about air, soundstage, treble, bas or stuff like that. I take songs I don't know by heart and do a A-A-B demo, is the music better with 'X' or with 'Y'. No Hifi mumbo jumbo, just better music.
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by mongo
Hi Efraim. Totally agree with you. Attention to detail in installation is clearly important with any gear. Probably more so as it gets more expensive.

Lay out the boxes to best effect, make sure all connections are as clean as possible and properly star earthed, all tightening done effectively, with cables dressed correctly. But then just stop. Know that it's done, forget it and enjoy the fruits of the above detailed labour.

Best of luck withn the experiments if you can't though. Paul.
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by Efraim roots
mongo wrote:
quote:
But then just stop. Know that it's done, forget it and enjoy the fruits of the above detailed labour.


I agree. I just haven't reached that point yet.

I stringed it up to get it running but now when it's burn in I want to make those final details perfect.

There is also one other big benefit of knowing which of your standard power cords that sounds best. Because you could move the best sounding cables towards the source.
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by mongo
Well no one can fault your dedication!

Hope you get it sorted to your satisfaction soon.
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by graham55
Indeed, then this thread might go away!
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by mongo
'Lo Graham. I haven't checked, but I'm fairly certain you're not compelled by anyone/thing to read it?
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by JWM
quote:
Originally posted by Efraim roots:
...I want to make those final details perfect.

There is also one other big benefit of knowing which of your standard power cords that sounds best. Because you could move the best sounding cables towards the source.


Surely the easy solution is to try your mains cables in every combination to see which is best? Though you must give each combination the correct amount of time to warm up before judging.

So, plug everything together in 'arrangement 1', making a note of which mains cable is which.

Switch on and let it warm up until fully on-song (3 days to a week).

Have a good listen. Perhaps make a few written notes.

Switch off. Unplug and replug mains cables to next combination 'arrangement 2' - changing no more than one mains cable at a time, so that you know the effect each brings.

Switch on again and let it warm up until fully on-song (3 days to a week) ensuring this is for the same period as you did before.

Have a good listen (in the interests of fairness, to the same pieces of music, and at the same time of day on the same day of the week to try to get as near as possible to the same power demand conditions on the electricity grid). Make (or not) a few written notes as before, on the same criteria.

Repeat process ad nauseam until all combinations are exhausted. Compare notes and make final judgement/arrangement.

Note: none of this can be done until your equipment is run-in - at least six weeks, though it is likely to continue improve in subtle ways over anything upto six months.

Alternatively, plug-in, sit back and enjoy.
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by Steve2701
quote:
I stringed it up to get it running but now when it's burn in I want to make those final details perfect.

Ah, so you'll be starting on getting the room acoustics correct then...
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by mongo
quote:
Originally posted by Steve2701:
quote:
I stringed it up to get it running but now when it's burn in I want to make those final details perfect.

Ah, so you'll be starting on getting the room acoustics correct then...


Lol. You evil fellow. Big Grin
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by graham55
quote:
Originally posted by mongo:
'Lo Graham. I haven't checked, but I'm fairly certain you're not compelled by anyone/thing to read it?


Indeed not, but I just find it dispiriting to read posts from someone who is so obsessed with the sound of his equipment (or, in this case, the peripherals) that he has completely forgotten about listening to the music that it produces.

As such, the thread has a certain fascination for me.
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by Mike-B
I find it VERY amusing to read posts from the insanely obsessed with the sound of equipment peripherals that they completely forgot about listening to the music. I agree therefore that the thread has a certain fascination for me also.

And if the cloud bursts thunder in your ear
You shout and no one seems to hear
And if the band you're in starts playing different tunes
I'll see you on the dark side of the moon
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by winkyincanada
quote:
Originally posted by Mike-B:
I find it VERY amusing to read posts from the insanely obsessed with the sound of equipment peripherals that they completely forgot about listening to the music. I agree therefore that the thread has a certain fascination for me also.



Same for me. Or it may be that I'm just a troll. Either way Razz.
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by dave simpson
I find it pretentious some individuals find it distressing folks can't have a hardware discussion. If it were "all about the music" none of us would be here.

For those musically inclined:

get off the cross, we need the wood

- Tom Waits
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by graham55
Not so, discussion of hardware is what this part of the Forum is all about, but the OP here has gone way beyond obsessive. In my opinion, of course.
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by Roy T
Music is for listening to either alone or with friends and often at home but boxes, cables, racks and alike are for willy waving in public on forums.
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by winkyincanada
The original psot asked a very specific question. Was their ever a chance of getting a direct and credible answer? No. Assume someone came on and said "Oh yeah; I compared all those cords, then had them re-made with the direction reversed and compared them all again. The results were that Cord "D", reversed was the best." Would it mean anything? Anything at all? No, unless the tests and results were scientifcally and statitically valid. But we know that likely won't happen for this sort of stuff. Proper double blind audio equipment testing is not too popular 'round here for some reason.

The only way for the original poster to work this out is try it themselves, in their system, in their room, with their mains. Everything else is just all of us relating our views, be they borne of experience, training or tests. The forum is for information and entertainment. These sorts of threads ask only for opinions and as such fall clearly into the entertainment area. Thus the notion that some of us just find it amusing.
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by dave simpson
Sharing information and experience is what this place is for the last time I checked. If some are offended by the discussion of hardware, they do have the option to stay out of the Hifi room altogether or at least threads that offend them.
Posted on: 27 January 2010 by graham55
I'm not 'offended' by this discussion, just rather saddened.

Anyway, I've said my piece and I'm butting out to leave space free for those who find this topic of interest or use to them in their daily lives.

Graham